Reviews for Downtown Benny's Pizza in Port St. Lucie, FL

Mike the manager was super friendly and wanted us to be happy! Pizza was delish and we will be using them for delivery from now... on! Thank you Read more

We live very close to the Fort Pierce location and decided to try it. I called for pick-up but the person taking my order got... confused and decided to have the pizza delivered when I was going to pick it up! When i got to the store i found out that mypizza and antipasto were delivered not to my address but to the wrong address on my street. I was charged $30 for food i nevergot. The kid taking my order ruined our supper. Read more

Best Italian food in psl/Jensen hands down! The pizza, cauliflower pizza, pasta, sauce & down to the garlic rolls! Also an... amazing staff. Paul the manager & the cook Mike!! Already ordered twice this week, Highly recommend! Read more

Got pizza before and it was great .. order this for delivery last night it was so greasy we couldn't even eat it ( took pic... after serving plates) Read more

Downtown Bennys is the best ! Our family orders so often because the sauce is incredible, and the order is delivered fast. I... recommend 5 out of 5 ?? Read more

The Best Garlic rolls I've ever heard. The Cheese steak Stromboli was awesome & enough for two people. Pepperoni pizza was... fantastic. 5 stars Read more

Raw zeppole dessert. Had high hopes but was ultimately disappointed. My wife had an eggplant parm hoagie which wasn't very good.... The roll had no crunch, the eggplant wasn't crispy so turned out to be a very mushy hoagie. Read more

We got the flyer in the mail and since my wife and I moved to PSL 7 years ago from New York we decided to try Benny's. Large... Pizza (Pepperoni, Mushroom and Ricotta Cheese) was definetly Autentic to New York, boasting with flavor and very generous insize and very delicious. approved by the picky Pizza eater among us. House Philly Steak Grinder Wowser definetely in my top 3of Phillys I have tasted, it miht even be number 1, very tasty not too salty and the bread is great too, it is going to e awhile before I try a Philly somewhere else. Zeppolis Normally they come with 6pcs but as you can see they gave me extra, verytasty probably the best Zeppolis I ever had, I inhaled those with a cup of coffee. Teramisu as you can see it doesnt look ofmuch on the picture, it was very tasty though, wish there was more of it, I am used to get Teramisu as a slice but this will doand it was good. All in all Downtown Benny's Pizza is a great addition to Port Saint Lucie, we will eat there again, Welcome toPSL. Read more