Reviews for Goodfellas pizza in Jupiter, FL
Little hole in the wall pizza place. We ordered the large Everything Stromboli and it was more than enough for 3 people to... share. Can honestly say it was the best Stromboli I?ve ever had. The ingredients were perfectly cooked, the crust was crispy,and the marinara sauce was so good! Read more
I have eaten 2 separate meals from this location, the first time it was a Cheese Pizza and it was Delicious, the second time I... ordered the special which had a Pizza and Wings combo, the Wings were big and perfectly fried with a mild Buffalo sauce to topthem, they have several choices for the sauce but you will have to ask because I cannot remember them, the Pizza was orderedwith Pepperoni, it again was very tasty. The menu is complete with every dish you would expect at a full scale Italianrestaurant. Table service is available as they have about a dozen tables with a few outside. Salads to deserts, they have itall. Parking lot is shared with multiple businesses so finding a spot close can be tricky, but there is plenty of space. Read more
Wowed that i Finally found NY style pizza. For me there?s No going elsewhere!, Mom and Pop joint at it?s Finest!, dine in,... takeout, it?s All good! Read more
Did not have a good take out experience there. 3x it took to get the small order correct. Must have been an off day. I tried... calling for take out one thursday and called many times with no one answering the phone. Had to use another pizza place. Read more
Terrible service, rude older lady was completely overwhelmed and ignoring or talking over patrons, including myself when I asked... why my order wasn?t ready yet after waiting an excessive amount of time. Chaotic atmosphere - this level of bad service isn?tacceptable. Will not return to this restaurant. Too many other good pizza places in Jupiter to mess with this place. Read more
Overall a very great tasting slice of pizza. Great sauce to cheese ratio. Although the crust was a little soggy. A lot of flop.... Only thing holding this slice from being a 5 star slice. But as a New Yorker. Its great to find some decent pie around here. Read more
Ordered via phone call, the girl who took my orde4 was friendly. The pizza was tasty, hood crust, good sauce.
I've been there more times than I can count. It's pizza. It's good. It's not expensive. Stop looking for the perfect slice.... Additionally, there is a publix next door to buy alcohol and dessert. Read more