Reviews for Arthurs Island Kitchen in Key Largo, FL
We stopped in mid week for the first time! What a wonderful surprise for reasonable, excellent food in #keylargo! It's family... style, and kid friendly place! The food is delicious, cooked with mindfulness, and by order! A MUST try @MM 102.2! Withtraditional Floribean (Caribbean) food offings as well as many fish and beef entries! Do yourself a favor and stop in! You won'tbe disappointed! Read more
A great diverse menu. Thoroughly recommend the jerk chicken wings. Excellent service by Nicole. We chatted with Arthur about... 1970/80's cricket, what a lovely guy and great place!!! Read more
Fantastic food at a reasonable price. His vegetables are not the usual cheap squash etc. mix you get at all the other... restaurants. His is unique and wonderful! His whole yellowtail was about half the price as anywhere else, and delicious. Ilove the callaloo soup. Also, the curried goat, and the oxtail. I look forward to exploring his entire menu! Read more
Our friends recommended this place and we are glad they did. This is a small restaurant with unique dishes. I had the callaloo... soup and the oxtail. Both were very delicious. It was a bit busy but understandable for dinner time. Arthur came to our tableand talked to us. We will definitely return. Read more
We had conch fritters, seared tuna and a side salad...all of the food was amazing! The seared tuna was the best I've ever had!... Service was phenomenal! Great food, wonderful experience! We can't wait ro eat there again the next time we're in Key Largo! Read more
Great food! We had seared tuna and conch fritters. The service was the best we experienced in the keys. Very personable and... treated us like the only customers in the restaurant! We loved this place! Read more
Our last dinner after two weeks in the Keys. We head home tomorrow. Arthur's is my Best in the Keys for this trip. The food was... great. Arthur came out and talked with us. It has an old school Keys vibe, and it reminds me of my pop's resturant. I had themacadamia nut encrusted hog fish. Betty had crab cakes and coconut shrimp with mango chutney. John & Betty Read more
Excellent food and service. We had the stuffed Mai Mai, hog fish & cheeseburger which were all excellent. Captain Craig our... server was very attentive and efficient. House made cocktails were great too! Read more