Reviews for Hot Tin Roof Restaurant in Key West, FL
Amazing sunset dinner! Reserve a table. Food was amazing. Besides the amazing seafood duck was amazing. One of the best key lime... pies on the island. Adrian was an outstanding server. He was fun, and just an excellent server. The manager Audrae was veryaccommodating, and checked in on tables. All in all food and atmosphere were spot on while still being comfortable and fun. Read more
First I want to start by saying the service was incredible. Oscar was so tentative to us even though he also had a huge party at... another table. Also his recommendations were on point. My husbands steak was cooked perfectly and my scallops with shrimp andasparagus risotto, impeccable. I do not think I’ve had a desert as good as the Cuban bread pudding in a long time. Lastly, theview, amazing. Will definitely be back. Read more
Arrived ahead of my friend in time for a solo dinner. Hot Tin Roof was recommended and now I can second that recommendation.... It’s in a great spot, you can see the water from the patio, and the food and service were outstanding. Best key lime pieI’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot! Read more
We had an amazing dinner for our 1st time in Key West! They accommodated the hot sun by putting down the blinds as the sun... started to set. The food was phenomenal and our server was very intentional. Water was consistently refilled. We loved ourexperience and would highly recommend it. Read more
My wife and I visited Hot Tin Roof for our 25th wedding anniversary dinner. This place was fantastic!!! Wendy was great from the... moment we made the reservation. Oscar was our waiter, and he was equally great! We didn't get the best seat in the house per wemade this reservation later than we should have. However, they were able to get us outside to see the sunset after our dinner.We got the fried bread as a starter, do get this, and try not to order 2... We did get cocktails, I had the Hemingway Daiquiri,my wife got the Sunset Cooler, yum! For dinner my wife had the filet, and I had the seared scallops and shrimp. Both meals weredelicious! In honor of our anniversary we were graced with a slice of key lime pie and champagne. The entire experience frombeginning to end was top notch. Do give this place a visit if you get the opportunity! Read more
The place has a really good view especially of the sunset. We ordered an appraiser and the bread which was definitely the best... part of the meal. With the main course I got the swordfish which was cooked well but definitely under seasoned. My Fiance gotthe Ribeye stake which came with fingerling potatoes and asparagus. I don't think the season the sides at all and the asparaguswas so overcooked it was just moosh. For the stake being a 68$ dish it was honestly a very cheap cut I have seen better from anout back stake house. I know it's not a "stake restaurant" but if your going to charge that mush I would hope it would at leastbe a good cut. She also ordered it medium rare and it came out raw. The thing that was the most disappointing was the mix drink,it was some kind of daiquiri but it tasted like dish water. Are waitress was great though, she got us a new drink and apologizedand all and all was a good server. Next time we go back to key west we may try it again, you are definitely paying more for theview then the food though. Read more
We came for the sunset view (having missed the window to join our friends at Latitudes), and set our expectations according to... the uneven reviews here. We arrived early, but they accommodated us anyway, with arguably the best 2 top in the house forunadulterated views of the sunset. Our selections were incredibly tasty and satisfying. Service was the perfect balance ofcordial and attentive without being stuffy. They lowered the patio shades post sunset to block the chilly breeze. It turned outto be one of my favorite dining experiences in Key West to date. Read more
What an unforgettable night. We visited this restaurant with the family and had an amazing time. We ordered the filet mignon and... the salmon. It was amazing! We also had the key lime pie for dessert. Adrian was a great help! He even brought chocolate saucefor the key lime pie after our request. We were a special table, because there was a proposal that night and Adrian helped makethe process smooth and beautiful!!!!!! There are special accommodations they can make for occasions like this with champagne,rose petals, etc. Read more