Reviews for The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant in Key West, FL
Restaurant is hit or miss. Have visited before and their apps are decent, but currently experiencing a lack luster wine... selection, with an extremely tart key lime pie Read more
I would avoid this place at all costs. The only reason I gave 2 stars is because the server was great. The food was absolutely... disgusting. The appetizers were burned and extremely spicy. (Usually like spicy. This was insane). I ordered grilled shrimp.They had a foul taste as if they were left out for too long prior to being cooked. I didn?t eat them out of caution. The shrimpwere very expensive and only came with 5 shrimp and soggy French fries. This restaurant would fail if it wasn?t in the centerof other restaurants in a very busy town. Read more
Service was great, we were promptly waited on and food came out quick. However our meal wasn?t really all that good. Seemed... liked maybe the fryer oil needed to be changed because the calamari and my sons chicken finger basket was very off tasting. Porkbelly and scallops was small portion sized and honestly didn?t taste that great either. Read more
We came back from our fishing trip and had The White Tarpon cook some of the grouper and snapper we caught. They did an awesome... job! We also had fries, brussel sprouts and corn. The appetizers were meh. Our waitess was wonderful! The Rum Runner wasdelicious. Read more
We were walking around the harbor looking for some food & this place hit the spot. The key lime pie martini was to die for!! All... the fish was cooked perfectly and the service was great! Read more
We came across White Tarpon while walking around Key West. It?s right on the waterfront at the marina. The Key Lime Martini is... the best! The mussels appetizer with Cuban bread is amazing- the broth is tasty, you will want another loaf to dip in it (whichthey happily provide)! The service was great and everyone is so friendly Read more
Food here was absolutely delicious!! Grilled Mahi mahi was awesome and cooked to perfection. The green beans and potatoes that... came with it also went perfectly with the fish. The shrimp and crab appetizer was fantastic. Definitely the best thing I atewhile here at the White Tarpon. Read more
Staff was friendly BUT do not eat here if they are getting ready to close. We ordered the Fried calamari and Grouper bits. It... came out very quickly but calamari was super chewy and rubbery. NOT GOOD AT ALL. If I end up sick, I?ll know why. Such a shamethis place was great the last time we were here. Read more