Reviews for Polito's Pizza in La Crosse, WI

Pros: The pizza was amazing! We ordered a fresh pizza for the family and it was great! With some soft drinks, $34 for a family... of 4 (plus optional tip). This is the kind of place where you order at a counter - there is no server. Slices are big! Cons: Tocall it "no frills" is an understatement. For example, the men's restroom didn't have a doorknob or a lock - looked like peoplewere just setting the trash can in front of the door. Lots of places looked like a fresh coat of paint was about 30 yearsoverdue. Still worth it. Read more

I used to go to Politos pretty frequently when I worked downtown. But since covid, we've mostly been ordering it for delivery. I... recently visited for a quick slice with some friends and I had forgotten just how awesome it is fresh out of the oven with somegarlic knots. Read more

I've only had the garlic knots from here, but that's enough to keep me coming back. That and the fact that every time I've ever... stopped in, the atmosphere is inviting because the workers are actually in good spirits and having fun. The management here areobviously doing something right...definitely gives off the Mom & Pop shop vibe that I love! Read more

Kind service , pretty tasty pizza especially it being by the slice. It wasn't overcooked and still gooey . Would recommend for a... quick bite Read more

Great tasting by the slice pizza and incredible value. I took my wife and three kids here for lunch and I was very surprised... with my low total bill. Incredibly cheap price for great tasting pizza. Lots of different pizza slice options make itsatisfying for everyone in my family. Definitely worth the stop. Read more

The pizza maker and the pizza question person were amazing! The pizza was great as well! The female cashier with dark hair was... totally crabby and forsure seemed like she did not want to be there. She was super lazy and never smiled. Read more

Great place for a single slice or a large pie! Mom and kid approved, especially the mac n' cheese pizza. ????????

Wandering back to hotel, we stumbled across this pizza place. Had a Mac & Cheese slice & Hawaiian. Pretty good flavor. Never... tried m&c pizza, might give it a whirl again?. But you can?t go wrong with Hawaiian, pineapple and cheese? yum! Read more