Reviews for Aurelio's Pizza of La Grange in La Grange, IL

Waited too long for simple pizza and paid too much.. not mentioning rude owner. I don't recommend this place to anyone. Andrew... you can do better! Read more

Everything was perfect. Family atmosphere, great staff. The deep dish pizza was thick, loaded and delicious.

Awesome place to have dinner! Everything was delicious, the sauce on the pasta was perfect and the wings were meaty with great... flavor. Definitely recommend Read more

Had a birthday party here and Aurelio?s went above and beyond to help us out. I would definitely come here for a large... gathering. Pizza is my favorite in all south side. Read more

Won't be back, we were in on a Sunday night and treated very poorly by the hostess. To begin with, my husband doesn?t care for... Aurelio?s much, but as it was my birthday weekend I convinced him that we go. The hostess ignored us when we first walked in,when she did pay attention to us she asked if we were here to dine in, which I replied, yes, two please. ?It?s going to be a 15minute wait, we have one waitress? she told us. Even though there were only 4, maybe 5 tables in the restaurant and nobody waswaiting. We asked if we could just sit at the bar, and order a pizza there? She said no. As my husband and I looked at eachother confused, she said ?sooo go somewhere else? Or wait 15 minutes.? We obviously decided to leave as we felt we were unwantedcustomers. No apologies, or anything further was said from your hostess as we turned to leave. I understand there are staffingissues going on, but this was above and beyond rude. All we wanted was two waters and to order a pizza. As someone that workedin college at a pizza place, I know that doesn?t require much attention from a waitress. The hostess, who didn't seem to havemuch going on, could've sat us down, brought two waters - the waitress could've taken the pizza order, brought it when it wasready, and dropped off a check. That doesn't require much attention at all. Instead we were told to go somewhere else. Verydisappointed, I did message the restaurant first, to which I have gotten no response in 2 weeks now. Read more

This pizza was the worst I?ve ever had. Way too sweet, the dough on the bottom wasn?t cooked enough, pizza came cold, and the... whole thing tasted really off. Read more

We are located less than 10 minutes from the restaurant. We received our food 1hr after delivery order. (I understand, business... flow can fluctuate) when the food came, it was lukewarm, and it may have seemed if we were the last delivery on the route.Overall the pizza was good, just disappointed at the fact our food was not hot, given the close distance. Also, the value ofthe food was well over $100 and the breaded mushroom did not even make the tongue jump. You can eat a hand full without the riskof getting burned. The sauce itself was hot, wrapped in aluminum foil, but the rest of the food, If you prefer the food Hot, youwould essentially have to microwave it. Our first experience, truly wish it was better. (Cheese was also mixture of yellow andmozzarella) not sure if that the recipe, but once again. Decent pizza, figured it would be much better had it been fresh. Whenthe box was open, this is exactly how the pizza looked. Read more

I am not a local of this restaurant or Illinois, I am from the state of Michigan. I was not expecting this pizza to be this... good. We ordered a stuffed pizza, It was a small and it was more than enough for two people {me and my fiancé} The ingredientswere crazy fresh and when I say crazy fresh it's almost like they cut them up themselves right before putting them on a pizza.The sauce, Oh my God the sauce{We did ask for extra sauce on our pizza} I'm sure you see the pictures I have provided, thecamera does this pizza no justice. The server we had was also pretty damn nice, she was very attentive to our table and she madesure that our drinks was refilled. she also checked on us at a consistent rate. Read more