Reviews for Keatings Ice Cream in Jefferson Township, PA

Nice staff but ice cream was icy. Not creamy.

Best homemade ice cream I've ever had ????????

Fresh ice cream from their own dairy cows and blueberry bushes. Only 5 stars but the Cajun cocoa with jalapeños had no spice at... all, like zero jalapeño, and could not sample the lemon blueberry due to covid? No hand to hand transfer? Read more

Delicious ice cream everytime! We go at least once a year for the ice cream. Highly Recommend

Omg what a variety of Ice Cream flavors and fast and courteous service. I could not ask for anything more.

Great ice cream and service. So many flavors.

If you like the real thing, fresh from the cow, don't pass this place by! As you drive up it doesn't look like much, but once... you open the door you enter a new old world. Everything is yummy beyond belief, I know because they let you taste whatever youwant. Very friendly and sweet staff. Read more

Wow. Soo many flavors. Everything my husband and I tried was delicious. I especially liked the double peanut butter chocolate... (with peanut butter cookie dough). The staff is very kind and willing to take the time to explain the flavors and give samples.This place is a hidden gem. Read more