Reviews for Mama Cimino's Pizza in Lake Geneva, WI
Finally stopped in for dinner after always saying that "we need to stop in sometime". We were not disappointed! Great little gem... with very good food! The wings are huge and excellent. My pasta dish was delicious and the meatball sub was even better! Ourserver was so friendly and attentive! Prices were very reasonable. Thank you for the nice meal and enjoyable atmosphere. Wewill be back ???? Read more
Pizza is alright, pasta is pretty good. Kitchen staff are absolutely unacceptable. We ordered the pizza pictured here and it... came like this, folded in on itself and 3 hours late. When I called to dispute this clearly unacceptable pizza whoever was backin the kitchen on 9/11/2022 started yelling through the phone and cussing about how there's no way he messed up. He thenproceeded to argue with me back and forth about the delusional amount of faith he had in his own abilities. The absolute worstcustomer experience I've ever had and we won't be paying for this garbage, nor will we be patroning this place anymore for ourweekly Sunday pizza's. Trash Read more
It is lovely pizza place, Nick is owner, he got 40 experienced making pizza, he learnt from his Mom. The way to slide pizza is... interesting. The pizza is delicious ???? There are delivery service on Friday&Saturday until 3.00am, or other day until 01.00am, check on many promotion as buy one get one free etc. Welcome dine in with your family and friends. Read more
The food was amazing at Mama Cimimo?s! I had the Primo pizza and it was delicious. I also tried the fried calamari for an... appetizer and they were delicious. My wife enjoyed the pizza rolls. They were huge rolls! My daughter enjoyed the bbq chickenwings. A must try restaurant in Lake Geneva. Our waitress Charissa did an excellent job serving us! Read more
Was passing threw town so read there reviews people said the Italian Beef was great. So I thought I would give it a try. Overall... it was okay. The beef slices were sliced thicker than I'm use to seeing on a Italian Beef. It tasted okay a little chewy becausethe beef was cut thicker. Would have again if I was in the area but, I would likely try other Italian dishes on the menu ormaybe try the pizza. Read more
Delicious! So hard to decide, but went with the Big Bruno sandwich and a RC! So yummy! My daughter loved the tortellini and my... husband inhaled the Italian beef pizza with giardiniera. Very friendly staff, can't wait to go back and try something new! Read more
If it's late, everything else is closed and you absolutely have to eat... i would go to McDonald's or wait for breakfast. The... pizza is nasty. Sorry, I'm used to pizza with flavor. This place is worse than the typically bad midwest pizza. To you peoplesaying the pizza was excellent... I'm sorry that you've never had good pizza to compare to. Either that or you were too drunk torealize how bad it was. The calamari was a joke(see pic). For $12, i expect something other than overcooking the cheapest bagof frozen food you can find. Yes, that pic is really what we got for $12! The cheese curds could have been okay, but theyovercooked them with the calamari. It was just hardened breading. I tried this place before and it was just not good. This timeit was bad enough to complain about. Read more
I was married at Maxwell Mansion and we ordered Mama Cimino's for our late night food. Every single pizza was piping hot and... cooked to perfection. People were stacking their plates high and raving about the quality. My expectations were low since it waslate and we ordered a ton of pizzas, but Mama Cimino's DELIVERED! Thank you for helping to end our night with a bang. Read more