Reviews for Maddy's Mexican Restaurant in Lake Hiawatha, NJ

Absolutely fantastic. I ordered via door dash for the first time tonight. And I am completely and udderly blown away.... Everything is and was spot on! It was like one of mi amigos Madres just cooked for me in their kitchen. I will definitely bevisiting in person time and time again Damn that was yummy. Well done Maddy's well done !!! Read more

Everything was so flavorful! The tortilla soup was amazing, I tasted so many great flavors. Great portions for the price as... well. Great authentic Mexican cuisine. The staff was very kind as well. Read more

Got delivery. Ordered wet burrito, classic burrito, and nachos. I know delivery nachos typically a no go but these were damn... good. Guac was excellent steak was well seasoned generous portions and cut to the perfect size for nachos. Identified in thenotes on the order that the classic burrito should be made without beans and they nailed it. Seems small but I’ve had manyorders where the staff seemingly ignores the notes. Seemed to give a double portion of rice in lieu of the beans which was notnecessary but much appreciated by the one that ate it. Smothered (wet) burrito was FANTASTIC. The salsa poblana sauce wasphenomenal. The flavors and balance were excellent and this dish really stuck to the authenticity they advertise. I will orderagain Read more

Great food and great friendly people!!! Would bring all my friends and they would leave very happy with this family owned and... operated restaurant Read more

This has been a great local go to for quite a long time now! The staff is always so friendly and the food is always delicious!... If you get a chance to try their birria tacos, do it!! Read more

My dinner (Chicken Sopes) was quite good. The guacamole left a little to be desired. The churros for dessert were a nice... recovery however. Don’t know much about service since I’ve only ordered online, but the cashier was super friendly and thefood was always ready on time. Read more

My friends and I went there for her birthday dinner since we had been told the food was amazing. I have to say We were all... disappointed. It was good but not amazing by any means. It lacked flavor. What was even worse than that was how hot it wassitting there. There was only one other couple in the whole place so it wasn’t do to body heat. It was very on comfortable andembarrassing to be sweating during a sit down dinner inside. I am Sorry to not have anything good to say for a little localplace. Read more

I want to like this place... The service was excellent and friendly. The food came out in a timely manner. But it is sooooo... bland. Where's the authentic Mexican taste?? The wet burrito specifically. Better off going to Chilly Willie's or Tito's forthese prices. Read more