Reviews for Timber Creek Pizza Co in Lake Mills, WI
Great food, fast, friendly service. Reasonable prices. Fun decor with a casual, rustic north-woodsy vibe. Clean restaurant and... clean restrooms. Consistently good. We've been going here for years and have never been disappointed. We always get the BLT suband a chocolate malt. I highly recommend both. Read more
I ordered a Philly cheese steak. For me that would be steak cheese onions and peppers. I got lettuce tomato mayo that had melted... into a milky liquid. I got it to go and by the time I had crossed the parkway the sandwich was soggy. I do not like hot lettuceand I was not asked what I would want with the sandwich. Also, I walked into the restaurant and four minutes later, that is whenI was acknowledged. The 2 guys that were there when I walked in were doing ice cream stuff and totally ignored my presence.Then when the third person showed up carrying ice cream containers he said hi but continued with the ice cream stuff. I didconsider leaving but thought I should stay and see how it goes. This is my first time there so, I don't know. I really wasn'timpressed. ...sorry guys???? Read more
I was so surprised!! I used to love this place! I ate here for the first time in years today and it was awful, and I feel awful... saying that! The salad was small and very expensive but that wasn?t even the problem! It was soggy and warm I couldn?t even eatit, and the lemonade was bad too! I would always crave there lemonade and it must have changed because it was very watered downand tasted old. I don?t know if I?d come back sadly. The positive was that the employee?s were kind! Read more
I hadn't been here in a very long time. I would give them a zero if there was one available. We went in for ice cream, sat at... the counter, had four young people walk by filling orders and delivering food to tables. No one made eye contact with us oracknowledged us in any way. After almost 10 minutes we left. We will not be back! Read more
Timber creek is an excellent joint. The food here is great; our favorite at Howell Building Care is the meat lovers pizza. They... do a family meal deal which feeds several people. The ice cream here is awesome too. It's an affordable stop, and they deliverhigh quality food for every meal. I highly recommend a visit here. Read more
Yummy pizza, subs, and creamy ice cream (including blue moon!). The take and bake pizzas are just as terrific as in-restaurant,... though the website/online ordering is finicky and you can't just create your own. Read more
The pizza was really good. The cheesy garlic bread was good. The orange dreamsical shake was ok. Over all a good experience.... We'll be back for sure! Read more
Moose Tracks icecream was very good but the Barbecue Chicken Pizza was disappointing. Toppings were runny and sliding off the... pizza. Barbecue sauce wasn't very good either. Read more