Reviews for Pizza Paul's in Lakeville, NY
Ordered a sub with a side of onion rings and battered mushrooms and my onions rings were delivered soggy and laying in a layer... of grease. I mean would anyone eat these? This place is going down hill lately Read more
My review requires an update. I originally gave Pizza Paul's 5 stars because it's been my favorite for about 22 years. Evidently... inflation has struck the pizza business. Slice used to be HUGE! Around $5.00 for a slice that took up a medium pizza box but now2 slices for around $10.00 will fit in the same box. Too pricey for me. Read more
Ordered a large special, large pizza with pepperoni and two dozen well done wings. The pizza crust was very thick, the sauce,... cheese and pepperoni left like 3 inches of crust on each slice of pizza! I ordered the wings well done and they were not theslightest bit crispy. Very disappointed with the meal tonight. It will be a while before I order from here again. Read more
Second time our order was wrong. One time pizza was burned. Sauce is very sweet. If you order pepperoni, you have to steal... from other pieces to get even four slices on one piece. We ordered a sheet and could hardly tell the plain cheese from thepepperoni. Will not be coming back. Read more
Ordered some wraps & wings for the family. Food quality was very poor and gross. First time customer and will not recommend or... return again. Read more
I ordered a large thin crust pizza and it was fabulous. We also ordered some boneless wings and they were great too. Staff was... nice also I would recommend to anyone. Read more
I was very disappointed. Not only did the gentleman at the front desk overcharged me for an order I did not place, but the two... subs that I ordered were absolutely terrible. The bread was the consistency of croutons. The lettuce was brown and wilted. $24for two poor quality subs. Read more
Food is good when they actually listen to what you order. I'd say 80% of everything i order ends up coming out with something... wrong with it. I order exact menu items, no changes and somehow it gets messed up almost every time. Read more