Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta in Lakewood, CO
Service was fast and everything we ordered (pasta, pizza, salad) was excellent! Definitely get the garlic bread. You won?t... regret it. Read more
Loved this place but would be cool if they let us get food an hour and a half before they close. Wasn't even nine. They close at... 10 according to the website and hours posted on the door, but they told us they're closed. The guy seemed upset that customerswere coming in the store, and the open sign was on. Update: I noticed they changed their hours online only after this review.That's a pretty dishonest business practice. I've been going to Anthony's for many years but no longer based on ethics alone. Read more
Ordered about 850pm. Put on hold then hung up on. Called back and placed an order for large pizza with pepperoni and olives.... Picked it up at 920pm. Got home and found a soggy pizza of olives, mushrooms, and sausage. Allergic to mushrooms. Called themat 935, no answer... guess they don't answer once they close. Had to place a separate order from domino's. Left Anthony's amessage expecting a refund. No one returned my called. Had to make a special trip down there to get a refund. Read more
As someone else said, for NY style pizza this is the closest thing you can get, I wasnt too disappointed but I have some... thoughts. If you can't make garlic knots with the same dough you're using for pizza, change up the dough recipe. Every NY styleplace SHOULD have garlic knots, they are a staple, every NY native knows you get garlic knots and marinara when you order alarge pie. The pies could be bigger as well in comparison to traditional NY style pizza. I couldn't get buffalo chicken on mypizza because it would "smoke up the oven", but other pizza places do it as a staple menu item so I dont understandthat? Review written by a NY native who's father worked in a pizza shop most of her young life. I am a huge critic of goodpizza, and while this pizza IS good, I would not consider it NY style pizza. It's just not quite there. Read more
We ordered a large pizza with mushroom, green pepper and pepperoni and the pizza had 0 flavor. It was also undercooked and the... pizza box was collapsed down on the pizza when it was delivered. Very, very disappointed and we will not be eating here again.Only redeeming quality was the cheese sticks which were good. Read more
Great pizza, nice staff but the price is really unreasonable I paid $12 for 2 slices of pizza.
Great pizza! Just moved here and have been trying all the NY style places around. This has been my favorite so far. Dough/crust... has a good flavor, sauce and cheese spot on for NY style. Will definitely be back, especially since this place is less than 2miles away from my apartment lol. Read more
Got here at 9:05 to get some food says they close at 9:30 and they had locked the doors and were counting the register.