Reviews for Granny Scott's Pie Shop in Lakewood, CO

I did give Granny another shot - and very glad I did. My last experience must have been an off day. This go around the empanada... was flaky and crisp and perfectly cooked. The mixed berry pie was phenomenal. moist, flaky and left me wanting to take the wholepie home! My first experience here was not quite what I hoped. Staff was friendly and the restaurant clean. I ordered theempanada meal, with a slice of triple berry pie. The empanada was dry and slightly overcooked. It really needed a good deal moresalsa than one small container. The filling was good, but too much crust to filling. If it were less done, that might not havebeen an issue. It wasn't so bad to send it back, but was enough to think twice before ordering again. Likewise the pie neededmoisture. Still, I would try this place again. Many of the pies looked fabulous. Read more

This was my first time here. We ordered 2 whole no sugar added apple and blueberry pies, both double crusted. We ate them way... too fast. They were fantastic. Read more

Food here is old fashioned, I think. Made by someone in the back with common ingredients and presumably fresh fruits and creams... and whatever else that goes into pies. I've had their pies about 3 times. I had their strawberry rhubarb pie, their coconutcream, and their peach. Flavor was pretty good. Not the best. Way too much crust for the amount of filling. I prefer my pies tohave more filling. The crust is kind of buttery but also way too much flour in my opinion. Has definitely a high flourtaste. Price seems way too high. Around 20 for pies. If you're craving some granny style, not the kind that's amazing atbaking pies but just some ordinary grandma, then this might do it for you. Also the place has a weird urine smell, like they'rehoarding animals. I guess that adds to the whole granny's house feel. Read more

Four of us stopped in for a slice of pie about 30 minutes prior to closing time. The young lady at the counter was very helpful... when we asked about (many) different pies, and we ended up getting her recommendation, the Peanut Butter pie - to die for! Excellent from the first bite to the last. Our friends got the Boston Cream, which they said tasted excellent, but the cakelayer was a bit dry. Definitely coming back, maybe for a whole pie! Read more

The best homemade pie shop! I found this gem years ago. I wanted pies not made on an assembly line and real lemon meringue pies.... Boy, did we get lucky! All the pies here are scrumptious and their breads (banana nut, zucchini, etc) and lunches are delicioustoo. Order ahead around the holidays...you'll be so happy you did ?????? Read more

I raved about your pie shop until last week. I drove there from Westminster just to buy a slice of lemon meringue pie for... myself and a friend. First, the young man at the counter said you were out. Then a young woman double checked the fridge andfound half a pie left. She cut a piece and put it in a bag while I looked at buying a slice of chocolate mousse pie you had. Iwas heartbroken when I got home and looked at these pieces of pie. So pathetic and not appealing. I?ve purchased a slicebefore and the lemon meringue was beautiful! Featured the stiff high beauty of the merengue. This did not. I had egg on myface when my guest looked at your slices of pie. Sigh Read more

Great little independent pie shop and cafe. We tried the lemon meringue, blueberry cheese pie and NY cheesecake. Everything was... great especially the lemon meringue which was perfectly tart and not overly sweet. They also have a breakfast menu, savory potpies, sandwiches, cookies, pastries, ice cream and good coffee. This is a hidden gem in Lakewood and apparently has been aroundfor 30 years. Read more

I come here all the time to get pies! Today I had time for lunch? what a treat! I got a pastrami sandwich, broccoli cheddar... soup, and a pie of blackberry pie to go. The sandwich and soup were amazing! The customer service here is always great and ILOVE seeing all the young hardworking people inside! Lunch was great! I?ll be back! Read more