Reviews for Fat Cat Pizza in Lancaster, OH
I use to love Fat Cat Pizza but the last two times, especially this last time was horrible. The sweet sauce tasted like canned... tomato paste loaded with sugar. I ordered a large veggie pizza and it was undercooked and soggy. I assumed the toppings would befreshly sliced and on top the pizza but they were under the cheese which made the toppings undesirable, not to mention the factthat with the toppings hidden underneath the cheese you really can't tell what all is on it or how much. I loved their sweethouse sauce in the past but this time is was way to sweet and way too much sauce on it to the point it was to sweet to eat. Ihad to let the pizza cool down enough so I could lift the cheese off and scrape off all the sauce and old looking old tastingdices onions that appeared to be pre bagged and diced. I also ordered a small pepperoni pizza. The pepperoni was also underneaththe cheese which made it slimy and greasy. I would think pepperoni would be on top so it would become crisp like most peoplelike it. Very disappointing and dissatisfied. F- Read more
Our kids school gave my child a coupon for a free personal pizza for doing good in school. When we went to redeem it we were... told it was from last year and was expired even though there was no expiration date on the coupon anywhere. The manager was verynasty about it. Read more
Food is always great..we were not offered any refills and we sat there fourty minutes after eating and had to ask for our check... ...no one asked if we needed anything..if you order out it take hour and half to get pizza so we thought be easier to eat in...they had several empty tables and three dirty ones ...love your pizza but a refill would be nice if we sit there that longwaiting to get food then fourty five minutes to pay for it.. Read more
Best pizza I've ever tasted.. the place to go when your craving a slice.. good atmosphere, friendly staff
My favorite pizza by far. The owners are great people and the staff as well. Friendly service and conversation. The food is... outstanding!!! Read more
Refused to give me my pizza? Said I had to use the drive through to pick up. Was told it was good. Not worth the 30+ minute... frustration after pick up time to get my food. Apparently the restaurant is good for dine in but still too Covid ridden toallow the transfer of pizza in a cardboard box. Read more
Very good thin crust pizza. Crispy with quality toppings. Solid salads. The best I've tried so far is their wings. Absolutely... perfect! They don't put anything on them, just fry them naked like a proper Buffalo wing. Their process produces moist,extremely Crispy wings. You'll eat more than you think so order extra. Read more
Went through the drive thru. They were very busy and we had to wait for the pizza. The pizza was pretty good. Not the best but... not the worst. Read more