Reviews for Columbo's Pizza in Lancaster, PA
Our company ordered 10 pizzas. The bread was so dry and hard, the cheese was overcooked, and there were 2 boxes marked bacon but... neither had bacon (with 23 witnesses may I add). I called the place to see if maybe the boxes got switched with another order.The man I talked to said he personally made the pizzas, used high-quality bacon, and that the cheese probably boiled over it. Hewas very hostile about it and I never got a word in after that. He just kept questioning my taste buds and I told him that Iwasn't the only one complaining. I just told him that I am not entertaining his argument and will just take our businesselsewhere. Besides the fact he admitted, there were supposed to be 3 boxes of bacon and we only received 2. Read more
New owner that is passionate about the food. He's worked in the business for 20+ years.
Skip this on your journey to find great pizza in Lancaster. Actually skip all of them and just go to Venice Pizza and Pasta.
Food was delivered hot and delicious! Not to mention reasonably priced. Will definitely order again.
I have never had a bad experience from Columbo's. The pizza is absolutely spectacular, and the price is fair. Every Wednesday I... order a pizza and side for my coworkers. They absolutely love Colombo's it has become a routine every week. I highly recommendstopping in for a good pizza or sub Read more
The worst pizza place ever they tried to not deliver my pizzas after I paid with credit card! I argued for 3 hours then got it... delivered cold and burnt. It reminded me of a frozen pizza from Walmart just bland and plain. You can?t make this stuff up! Ihave tried almost every pizza place in Lancaster and this is the worse by far. I found out they have had 3 write ups forcleanliness in the last few yrs. nightmare of a place! Read more
I can honestly say, I?ve never been disappointed! We order all the time from pizza shops in Lancaster and Columbos is one we... always end up going back to. Prices are great, delivery time estimates are almost always dead on and the food is great! Whatmore could you ask for? Their pizza is delicious and the Stromboli?s are AMAZING! The only thing I?ve gotten that wasn?t myfavorite would be the cheesesteak. Don?t get me wrong, it tasted really great just was skinny. Long story short it was lessbread and I think the same amount of meat so maybe I actually liked it better than other places. If you go, get a Stromboli! Ileft my review, now you go visit and make sure to do the same! Kudos to Columbos! Read more
New owner trying to make changes, quality declining. Please concentrate on what built Columbos, disregard changes for now. ... Quality will keep your business going, not a fan of quality so far. Read more