Reviews for Old San Juan in Lancaster, PA
The service was wonderful, the food tasted fantastic, and the drinks were amazing. Definitely a great spot for “special... occasion” dining. Read more
Being a Puerto Rican, a musician and a cook, this place is excellent. Nice upscale Puerto Rican food service. The food was... delicious! The atmosphere is beautiful, the music is perfect (Salsa Lo Mío) and the staff was supper friendly. I know there’splenty of great Puerto Rican places to eat at a lower cost but here you get what you pay for. Perfect date night and anniversaryfor the Mrs and I. Read more
So my husband and I decided to give this place a try. And I must say I am so happy we did! It was definitely good! The rice was... perfect! The food had all the perfect old school flavors. A lot of Spanish food goes light on the flavors in this day and ageand they do not lack! The prices are a little high for and appetizer for only 2 empanadias was 9 buck I do think they shouldserve 4 for that price. I do get it its a small home town business trying to succeed! But there is a few things they could giveand pull on. I'd love to see some more small Spanish things but I would definitely go back here! I just hope it is as good asthe first time when I go back! Keep up the good food Old San Juan! Thank you for the good hospitality! Read more
What a VERY nice surprise to find this restaurant! The building and decor is outstanding with a flair of the arts. The lunch... buffet was a bit warm but fresh and seasoned. Luis our server was courteous and prompt. We will definitely be back! Read more
Nice atmosphere with music. Our server Tyara was very friendly and welcoming, and attentive. The food was full of flavor. If you... are in Lancaster and are looking for foos that taste home cooked swing by Old San Juan. Read more
Well I was surprised that the servers didn't know spanish at all considering this is a spanish restaurant and when I went the... place was empty only 4 ppl that was eating so that being said food took and hour or more to make it to us considering the placewas empty I was disappointed on the slow service and the food it's definitely very over priced mofongo was $24 n they evencharge me $6 apart for the pollo guisado when it supposed to be a whole dish my husband order the white rice with bistec withonions and it's definitely not puerto rican bistec was good but mind you bistec cost $31 dollars 4 dishes ended up adding to a$149 check the piña colada alone was $10 dollars each thank God only ordered 2 but the server was very nice the mofongo washard but the rice n pollo guisado was delicious n they was so nice to let us sing my friend happy birthday and they even bringus plates n knife to cut the cake this place will be full of ppl if the price goes down on food Read more
My daughter and I went here looking for some good Puerto Rican food and we did not get it. We are highly disappointed with... everything from service to food. We ordered typical arroz con gandules, which was definitely reheated, tasteless and clumpy(should not have been served), the tostones were not good either, I doubt platanos were being peeled and cut in that kitchen.The meat was the only thing that looked fresh, but it needed some seasoning. I’m glad, I got some hot sauce to pour over food. I will never eat here again and I do not recommend. I suggest you go food shopping and cook. It’s what I do 90% of thetime ???? Read more
Absolutely amazing food. Was just to PR and this food ranks right up with the places we ate in PR. Staff was polite and... attentive, thank you Christal for an amazing dining experience! Ding dong baby ding dong Read more