Reviews for Fat Boys Pizza & Hoagies in Lewisberry, PA
The crust was perfectly cooked, the sauce was great and had just the right amount of cheese. The wings were crispy like we like... them and the sauce was phenomenal . Staff was friendly Read more
Hands down the best chicken fingers I have had. Tender, moist and the breading was perfect. Even had a pizza burger. Melted in... my mouth. New owners were just as nice and could be. Can?t wait to go back and try the pizza! Read more
I had a bacon cheeseburger sub, my father had an italian sub, and my mother a turkey sub. All were great, we also got a... pepperoni pizza to go to try for dinner and it was also good. Will be back. Read more
Stopped in today for lunch and the food was amazing. The new owners and employees were wonderful. The hoagie was awesome, pizza... was delicious and best wings I ever had. A must stop. Read more
First time going here. We got a veggie and an extra cheese pizza. We also bought their homemade apple pie and chocolate with... peanut butter icing. Everything was amazing! We are looking forward to going back here. Read more
I really enjoy the mexican food here. Tried something different this time. Epic fail on the cheesesteak. It tasted like it... was mixed with ?Manwich? and grease. The steak? was past its prime. The yellow ?stuff? in the photo is grease. Roll was sosaturated it was near impossible to pick it up. Absolutely gross. Could not stomach it - Gave it to the trash can. Was morethe consistency of a stew than a sandwich. Never again. Read more
If I could give it a zero I would. This place just opened and they were clearly not ready. Hour long wait for food with no... communication or heads up that it would be a long wait so we could decide to stay or leave. They take payment at order so youare stuck waiting. And, no attempt to try and compensate or get us to return for the lengthy wait or horrible service. I mean,you just opened...I may have given you another chance if you provided us a gift card or some incentive to come back! Not now! More details here... After waiting an hour, they brought out our kids cheese fries. That?s all...we had to ask them if they wereplanning to bring anything else and were asked what the rest of our order was. Then they brought 1 of our kids tacos (they bothordered the exact same thing) and it was cold. It took another 10 minutes to bring the rest of the food and wasn?t impressedwith anything. I ordered the chicken quesadilla with everything and it was brought plain and without any sour cream on the side.As the solution to their mistake, they brought a side of lettuce, tomatoes and onions but the tomatoes and onions were not dicedso just chunks. Will not be coming back!!! Read more
New ownership as of about June. The current menu (10/2022) is the simple black and white one ? they consolidated the menu and... now focus on pizza and hoagies so be sure to look for the new menu for ordering.\n\nI had a plain cheese pizza. The pizza edgewas not puffy/big. Tomato sauce was sweet and tasted good. Pizza was not oily. The pizza base was my favorite part of thepizza as it was perfectly chewy.\n\nIt looks like a family was running the place. They were working hard to get orders in andmake the food. They seemed friendly. The eating area looks a bit nicer than I remember. I?m sure to try some of the otheritems next. Read more