Reviews for Sarah's Pizza Lewisburg in Lewisburg, OH
2nd time we've gone here. Heard it was "bad", but thought we'd try it and not be sheeple. Had the bacon chicken ranch pizza,... mashed tater pizza, and BLT pizza. Definitely worth it. Thank God we can think for ourselves. Staff was friendly. Service wasfast. Food was excellent. Tried again tonight. Same results. Got a Taco salad - have an appetite. Its bigger than you'd think.Loaded fries - not bad. Turkey sub - good, just needed some Italian dressing and it's great. Overall, very pleased with thestaff, service, and food quality. Read more
We were visiting from out of state for the haunted cave, and this place was close by. And I am so thankful because it's... literally some of the best pizza I have ever had. It was quick too and the staff was super friendly. Would definitely eat hereagain if we come back to lewsiburg. Read more
Do you know when a Pizza is really awesome. Make it your first stop everytime you come up from Alabama to visit your mom. ... That's what I do. Mom loves it. There Deluxe is sooooo good. This time right b4 I left to go back home to Bama they were mylast stop in Lewisburg. Ordered a large Deluxe. Ate on it on the way down the road and finished it up when I got home. A truepizza shop. The staff is always friendly. Only suggestion. Recognize those who provide these freedoms and offer a Militarydiscount. Read more
Let me just say: I LOVE this place. If you love anywhere near Dayton, take the trek out to Lewisburg and try one of their... specialty pizzas. I recommend the mashed potato pizza. I know, sounds weird. But definitely worth trying. They also have greatregular options (pepperoni, deluxe, etc.). Great place to enjoy a meal and good company. Read more
Brad the owner is a great guy! Just had Sarah?s for the first time and I will be coming back for one once a week after my golf... league! Strict instructions from the wife. Thank you Brad for the great service and hospitality! 10/10 pizza! Pickle pizza isamazing! Read more
We have ordered from Sarah?s for years. Slowly the quality has went down and tonight?s pizza and sub delivery was more than... disappointing. The pizza was delivered over an hour after being called in and upon arrival was cold and even seemed tough andundercooked. Also requested and paid for extra cheese?. You be the judge of that in the pic below. Unfortunately, this will bethe last time we order from here. Save your money, it?s too expensive to throw away nowadays? call another pizza restaurant forquality! Read more
Our 1st time ordering here from TA truck stop. Experience was great but food was even better, definitely satisfied ????????... especially when you deal with good people! Order over phone was pleasantly quick & precise, so was the delivery ???? Keep up thegood work, thank you from a fellow driver. Read more
First time trying their pizza. It was really good and had plenty of toppings. The delivery driver was a younger girl and she was... very polite and arrived earlier than the scheduled time. They are also one of the only pizza places around willing to deliverwere I live. Will definitely be ordering again :) Read more