Reviews for Casa Antica in Lewiston, NY
Very good but not great. Right off the bat the hostess was busy talking to people on the street rather than being a hostess. And... seating my friends and I. That said, the wait staff was good and the menu very diverse. With generous portions. Nice locationand a great patio. Read more
Perhaps the best Ossobuco I've had in decades. From the first bite of our appetizers to our main courses, our palettes were... delighted. Our table of four enjoyed every bite. Portions were excessively generous and service was equally attentive andunobtrusive. Could not recommend higher. Read more
It?s been a while since we?ve been to Casa Antica solely due to its distance from our home. This evening?s meal was a wonderful... reminder as to why we need to come back more often. The food was so flavorful and delicious. Our server was personable, quick,and responsive to our every need. It was a busy summer Friday evening, but as a table of two, we weren?t effected. One of thethings that we discussed at our table was how every server and busser was in constant motion with purpose. No one stood around.I cannot say enough about the delicious food and excellent service. We?ve already planned our next visit with family. Read more
The meals here are pretty big. We had spaghetti with meat sauce and added an Italian sausage, Caesar salad, and bread with... dipping oil. We divided the meal between the two of us and I still felt like I over ate, plus I took some home. The hostessand our waitress were very friendly and helpful. The restaurant & bathrooms were clean. They also have a nice patio foroutdoor dining. Read more
My favorite restaurant ever! Delicious food and the best atmosphere. We frequent this restaurant about once a week and it?s... consistently amazing. Any time guests come from out of town we bring them to Casa. My husband?s family is from Italy and theyabsolutely love the food here and never want to eat anywhere else! Read more
My family had dinner at Casa Antica for Mother's Day. We started with the fried goat cheese appetizer and a shrimp special. ... Both were fantastic. Presentation was excellent and they tasted great. They bring a basket of fresh breads which were verygood, along with a dish of bread toppings/dip that were also unique and delicious. For entrees we had one margherita pizza(called personal pizza although it is a full size pizza), Risotto Capesante, two Seafood Scampi and a Vodka Rigatoni. Therisotto and scallops were perfectly done and very tasty. The presentation would do better in a shallow bowl than on a plate. The vodka rigatoni were just drowned in the sauce. Tasted good, but really excessive with the sauce. The seafood scampi wascooked very nicely and the lemon and wine sauce added the perfect light note to the meal. My only criticism was the fettuccine. The menu said it was homemade, but it really did not taste like it at all. Overall it was a wonderful meal. Our waiter wasvery attentive and provided a great experience. Prices are very high, so be prepared for that. Read more
If I could give this place more than five stars I would, they have a very unique menu but their specials are to die for! Not... sure I'm supposed to mention this but if you want a real treat ask for the P'nut special it's a Gnocchi mac and cheese withsteak. It's Not on the menu but it's to amazing. It's one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to! I also had thecowboy ribeye which is in the picture, probably one of the best steaks I've ever had. Read more
Waitress was excellent. Food was very good. Little pricey for pasta dishes. Outside dining was in a nice setup. They have a very... active outside bar and nice dining room inside Read more