Reviews for Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria by Fayette Mall in Lexington, KY

We went to Smashing Tomato Lexington for dinner with my wife and two adult daughters. I got the cobb salad. Loved the picked red... peppers. The girls got the fungi pizza but with red sauce. And, my wife got a pepperoni pizza. Love the dried herbs and oliveoil to dip the bread. Read more

I worked here for about a month and I can say that everything here is prepared with the upmost care and quality. The ingredients... are delivered fresh daily, the standards are set and each employee has the integrity and drive you hope to see. The staff is allpersonable and friendly all the way to the top of the chain. This store is led by one of the most competent general mangersI’ve had the pleasure of working under. Please give this place a try next time you’re around the mall area. -MR Read more

Usually good place for wood fired pizza. However I do not recommend going there 15 minutes before closing. Burnt pizza, barely... any toppings and for the win, they gave me the wrong soup (unless orzo has drastically changed!). The staff member who broughtout my order was courteous, but she was the only one. It took a solid 3 minutes for the person behind the counter toacknowledge I was standing in front of them anxiously awaiting for him to take my order. I did not discover the order wasincorrect and the pizza was on the verge of inedible until returning to Georgetown. I’m sure the rats in the dumpster enjoyedthis meal! Read more

Best pizza place in town. Love their pizza, sauce is amazing and it doesn’t hurt that they they serve decent wines and... beers. ???? wish they’d expand to other parts of the city! However, I’ve never felt compelled to leave a review untiltonight. I visited solo for a late dinner and didn’t realize I ordered in shortly before close. I offered to box my pizza. Thestaff insisted I stay while they closed down. They continued to wait on me-offering me refills and even a sample of bread andoils, even though they didn’t have to do so. They kept reassuring me to stay and enjoy my food. As I waited for my order, Ilistened to their exchanges with other guests and then me, they were ALL so genuinely friendly, happy and personable. Theyworked so well together and they put their customers’ needs first. Before I left I asked if they’d let me take their pictureto post alongside a review I planned to leave. I told them how rare it is for businesses to treat their guests this way and thatmeans a lot. They obliged. Thank you to these four -and one who clocked out before I left- for being so hospitable and happy.Smashing Tomato is lucky to have this great crew. ???? ?? Read more

I am not sure why I have never tried eating here and always assumed it was a fast food place. We had every intention of eating... somewhere else and due to an hour wait we decided to go somewhere else and landed here. We ordered the Dinner Special if whichconsisted of a 12" "Keeneland" Pizza and a Caesar Salad and ordered the Artichoke Dip in a small. The portions were very goodand all for a fair price (pictured). The Fire Cooked Pizza was Fantastic! The Artichoke Dip along with the pizza bread was alsofantastic. The Caesar salad was pretty average but it also came with some pizza bread and the Olive Oil/Vinegar and Spice blendmade this bread even better. This will definitely not be the last time we come here. Read more

This pizza is, hands down, the best. They have the perfect amount of desirable chew without dipping into toughness in the crust.... If it’s all about the sauce (and it is) theirs is the best. Get the spicy. We love their salad and try to recreate it at home.Their dipping options for the sheet music bread takes it all to the next level. It’s fast. It’s causal. What else do youwant?! This pizza lacks nothing. Go here and go often. Read more

First visit. Very clean. Friendly staff. I ordered a ceasar salad with blackened chicken. Good salad with a good amount of... dressing covering the whole salad. I was expecting the chicken to be warm but it was served cold. Not that there is anythingwrong with that. Just describing the dish. Plate came with 3 pretty decent side pizza shaped "breadsticks" basically largeslices of pizza with just the dough and seasoning. Good bread. Had some marinara with them. Personally I didn't like it. Wasalmost like tomatoes were put in a blender. I like marinara thicker with some flavor. Overall great meal and first experience.Would recommend and eat here again. Not sure the red floors was the best idea. This has got to be a pain to keep clean. BUTyou'll definitely know if they didn't so that may be a plus. Read more

Ordered some takeout online. Simple process. Got a 12” Margherita Smashed (spicy Arrabiata sauce) and a large Original... Chopped Salad. Drove over to pick up; the order was ready. Very disappointed when I could not get any plates or extrautensils. Pizza and salad dressing were excellent, but the support for takeout was disappointing. Read more