Reviews for Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria in Lincroft, NJ

Worst ever! This place is very inconsistent. Tonight I ordered a Sicilian pie with pepperoni and peppers. The pizza was under... cooked, soupy, unmelted cheese and cut irregular. When I called to let the manager know he said I?m sorry I?ll let the staffknow. How does that help me? He offered another pizza but we are past wanting another pizza in the same night ?would have beena better gesture to send a gift card or credit my credit card. Keep the apology and please keep the pizza too! This is not theplace to go. Read more

I enjoy ordering in or eating at Attilio's. The pizza is decent. I also enjoy their burgers ???? and fries. They cook the burger... exactly the way I order it, and my fries are never greasy. The staff is pleasant enough that you don't mind returning to eatagain. Read more

Had a lovely group dinner there. They were very accommodating to our group and took care of us well Food was pretty good.... Service was excellent and the atmosphere was a pizzeria restaurant atmosphere. Read more

Actually insane how inedible the food was. Not even being dramatic. Wow I mean it was a life changing experience. What on earth... was that. I am scared for life. Currently in Acme looking for ANYTHING other than attilios gnocchi and seafood risotto. Read more

Ordered the Rigatoni a la vodka from here for years. Even when I moved away, I would go out of my way for it. Now it doesn't... taste the same. Chicken tastes rubbery, sauce is watered down and has no taste. Bring back the old and better recipe! Read more

If I could leave zero stars I would. Probably the worst food at a pizzeria I have ever experienced. Had a chic parm Stromboli... and my husband had a plain slice and a chicken slice. The chicken was like rubber and the food had zero taste to it. Awful. Ifyou're headed here turn around. Read more

We live locally and have tried this place about 5 or 6 times to give it a chance - their pizza is not very good. Gave it many... chances, tried different slices and pies. Their customer service is not very good either. Many better options for good pizza inthe area. Read more

First time trying this place. Ordered delivery and the pizza arrived a complete mess, with all of the cheese and toppings on one... side and the rest of the pizza completely bare. The pizza was totally inedible. Restaurant owner blamed the driver, didn'tapologize, and didn't offer any recourse. Told me not to order again if I wasn't happy. Absolutely horrible quality pizza andeven worse customer service. Oh, and for the record, it almost certainly wasn?t (only) the driver?s fault. For the one or twoslices that were somewhat intact, the cheese and toppings immediately slid off when I picked the slices up. Read more