Reviews for Rusted Silo Southern BBQ & Brew House in Lizton, IN

I have to start off saying my meal was absolutely delicious. The beef brisket was very moist and tender. I soaked part of it in... the Carolina Mustard sauce, and the other half in the Habanero Bourbon sauce. Both sauces were flavorful, but the kick of thespice in the Carolina Mustard sauce made me want it even more. The Collard Greens and Zucchini & Tomatoes sides were verydelicious. So much so I couldn't stop eating them. To top off the meal I had a slice of Bourbon Pecan Pie. So divine and sinfulthat I enjoyed each and every bite. The pecans had a nice crunch, the custard was sinfully sweet, and the crust was flaky.Unfortunately, I can't say that my wife and son had the same experience. The pulled pork was good, but the potato salad and coleslaw sides weren't that good. The potato salad looked and tasted like dry mashed potatoes, and the cole slaw had a very strongtaste of cilantro. The chicken was very wet a bit more than moist, and the Mac & cheese was creamy, but wasn't sure if it was abeer or cheddar cheese. For dessert my wife had the peach cobbler. She found it to have too much cinnamon. The space is far toosmall for the seating and waiting areas. If it isn't the people in line to order who are far too close to half the tables, itfeels as if there isn't enough room to wait because one is backing and/or bumping into something or someone. The restroom is sosmall that there isn't enough room for more than one person. There should be a sign to use the foot pedal to pump the water towash one's hands. Next time we will order takeout. Also, would have preferred rating 2.5 because pur experience was between okand dislike. Read more

We were traveling along the highway and saw signs for this place. They had an average rating of five stars so we had to check it... out. The ribs were delicious, the brisket melted in my mouth, and it was quick easy in and out service to get us back on theroad. I have a dessert too if you can. They're small enough that they just hit the spot after the meal. Definitely recommend. Read more

If you?re looking for an authentic bbq shop with character, history, and an ambiance you can?t find anywhere else, look no... further. This is it. The pulled pork is a textbook classic, sauce is great, Mac and cheese pairs well with the style and thepotato salad is original and very tasty. Good BBQ isn?t made at a national chain, it?s made in small town shops like this. Welldone. Read more

I'm really happy that we find this place on our way home. However, I'm very disappointed that I live so far away from it. I... ordered the brisket sandwich with some extra pulled pork. I also ordered the sausage sampler and peach cobbler. Everything wasdelicious. The sauce was what very good and not sweet which I don't like sweet sauces. The only issue was that the sausages werea little tough but still great. They come with a small dish of some sort of cheese dip which was also very good. I wouldrecommend the stop if your ever close by, it is worth it. Read more

O.M.G. (Gosh ????). As ya drive by you see the smoke billowing from the chimney. Walk in to see a giant rotisserie machination... rotating delectable meats over wood? pork, brisket, chicken, sausage. The sides: amazing. The sauces: amazing. Owner wastelling some tourists visiting off interstate: if its on the board its excellent. True so true my friends. Go here! Read more

Possibly the best brisket I have ever had. I've worked with the staff before during a plumbing renovation and everyone was... always kind and helpful as they were today. Small town feel with a big town taste. I would highly recommend checking out thisplace if you haven't had the chance. Read more

Hands down, the very best southern bbq from here to Tennessee. I actually had given up on finding good bbq in Indiana, but this... place knows how it?s done! Will stop every time we come through. ???? Read more

Fantastic brisket, ribs, slaw, grits and Mac and cheese. Everything was very tasty. Service was friendly and fast. Cool vibe... to the little joint. Owners wife was friendly as well as the other staff. We will be back! Read more