Reviews for Brendon's Catch 23 in Louisville, KY
We arrived 15 minutes early and while we were waiting at the bar not even a few minutes later they had our table ready. Service... was fast and efficient and we were out within an hour and 30 minutes. I can't remember the name of the drink pictured but it wasfantastic. Everyone loved the drinks they got. The steak I ordered was medium plus and it came out closer to rare, same witheveryone else at the table. We all ate them and they were really good but I would have ordered it more done had I known they'dcome out less. Other than that we had a great experience and I would return again! It was such a nice place inside and staff wasfantastic. Read more
I recently visited Louisville for the first time and was told Brendon's Catch 23 was a must in the city. I had dinner on a... Saturday night and was impressed with the service, food and ambience. The hostess was very sweet, the bartender made me one ofthe best old fashions I've had (the ice cube inside the drink had the restaurant's logo stamped on it), and our waitress wasvery knowledgeable and professional. The food was delicious and the portions very fair. I was impressed with gem and willdefinitely go back if I'm in the city again. Great family business! Read more
Private Dining Room Experience: I want to start off on the GOOD notes here, the Bartender who served us an old fashioned before... we sat for dinner was AMAZING, I really regret not remembering her name, but she was wonderfully knowledgeable and experiencedin customer service! Alyza, who I also had worked with for booking the room, was fantastic! The food and drinks were also up topar on what I would expect when you spend $900+ on dinner. However, food is NOT the only thing that makes a luxury diningexperience special, customer service, ambiance, and other factors come into play; which brings me to the BAD part of my review:As you can see from my photo attached to this review, we are in direct line of sight with other customers tables, what is"Private" about this room? I don't mind being near the kitchen at all but the fact other customers are watching us eat dinner isnot acceptable. Yea there is a cheap drape to block off the room but it was never offered to be closed and we wouldn't havewanted it to be anyways due to the heat of the room. We were offered a specialized menu but never a private dining menu, thiswas a little confusing to me but there is apparently a difference according to their website? Our server, Sam, was veryattentive. He constantly checked in on us and made sure we were doing okay. He did seem very new or inexperienced in this levelof dining however, we were hoping for a little more enthusiasm and assistance through ordering but were kind of left to makemostly our own decisions as first time patrons of this restaurant. Overall my main recommendation is steer clear from privatedining and just book a normal table, if you need to do private dining, do it right and go to Jeff Ruby's. Other than that, greatfood and great drinks. Read more
Excellent service, great hosts and amazing food. You will need a reservation to eat here. Amaretto sour was made to perfect and... our waiter had a foreign accent that gave a top feeling to be served. When we arrived we received custom menus with happybirthday, specialized, for the birthday girl. Such a great experience here. Read more
Even with our 8pm reservation, we still waited 30 minutes for our table. Tha host was aware this was a birthday celebration but... failed to tell our server who was otherwise magnificent. He was knowledgeable, polite and attentive. Food was good, portions didnot equate to the price but the atmosphere was also nice. Butter cake was amazing for dessert Read more
Definitely a great dining experience. Waitress was very knowledgeable regarding the menu as well . Had multiple... suggestions. We went with jar of warm crab meat in a butter sauce and served with pita on the side . Excellent and Definitelyrecommend this appetizer. I ordered the filet mignon . Cooked exactly as I ordered it . Recommend getting the mashed potatoesas well . They were excellent Read more
Always an amazing experience! Food and service were phenomenal. Table-side smoked old fashion was an experience in itself and... worth a trip. No better way to finish a night out than a plate of buttercake with bourbon ice cream. Read more
The dining experience here is great. The service was pleasant and the staff very welcoming. I was pleased with the flavors, the... menu is full of various options. Went with the Tuna Tar Tar as an appetizer and it did not disappoint. The preparation ofChilean Sea Bass (as the main course) was spot on. My wife had the Scallop plate, I thought the risotto was a great complimentto the plate. Presentation was excellent! Read more