Reviews for Goodfellas Pizzeria - Baxter Ave. in Louisville, KY

They served really good pizzas. Their vibe is neat. They have two separate rooms. One is general for everyone and other one is... called speakeasy, it is for 21 and up. I like that room, it is more private than in other rooms. I will come back for more. Read more

Well I?m not the first but I had to come in. I was going to order from a local pizza place but they closed at 11pm. Someone... suggested Goodfellas and it wasn?t just open it was bustling, bright and alive! Not only were they were creating and bakingfresh pizzas, there were 25 people in line waiting to but a slice! The facility was clean and looked well maintained. Ordering awhole pie took a while but by the slice was quick and efficient. The staff were alive for that hour of the evening andattentive! Overall great experience!! Highly recommend! Read more

I enjoyed the pizza quite a bit. I love how open the restaurant is and I like being able to see the staff make the pizzas in... front of me. Someone complained about the pizza being cut uneven. Yeah some slices were the size of two and some were the sizeof one but how many people are going to eat one slice anyways?!? That just saved me time by picking up an oversized slice. ????I always ask for extra sauce when I get pizza but I wanted to try as is. I got extra sauce to go and the pizza was even better.Nothing like extra sauce. ???? Definitely will be back again. I also liked my chocolate chip ???? Read more

This is some very nice new york style pizza. You can order by the slice or get a proper pie. Food was very tasty. Reminded me of... a higher end pizza place in new york city. Very, very good pizza. Read more

Loved the shockingly huge pizza..the "forget about it". The only thing that was a downside was the paper plates..I would offer... up small metal plates and maybe a small slicer because the pieces were so huge. Paper just got all wet and started rippingand getting holes in it when you tried to cut the pieces into edible bites. Ambiance was awesome..clean and relaxing andstaff was very friendly! The pizza was delicious and quite the conversation piece. It's not too often you need to get thecamera out for dinner! Read more

My friends and I went to watch games during March Madness. Lots of places to sit and watch games on couches or at tables. The... ambiance is great. The breadsticks were awesome and pizza was good. The pizza is New York style by the slice out of the case oryou can special order anything. I really enjoyed my first visit here and I will be back again! Read more

A great location with a killer vibe. The atmosphere is inviting and great for people watching. The cocktails are fantastic and... everything is made in house. Pizza and salads are good! We enjoy the back lounge and sitting on the patio! Read more

I would have to say this place awesome... The atmosphere was good the employee were very friendly and of course the Pizza was... amazing 2 thumbs up... This place was clean as a whistle ... I recommend this place to anyone looking for a great spot tohangout and some great pizza ????... Read more