Reviews for Milantoni Italian Restaurant in Louisville, KY

We called ahead and there was no wait so decided to give it a try. That should have maybe been a red flag. When we got in and... were seated by a worker randomly pointing to the center of the room, but no one came to take our drink order or even providemenus. It was myself and husband and 2 kids. He wanted to just leave after 10 minutes of 0 acknowledgment we were there but Inoticed workers kept poking their heads out and looking at us. So I got up and asked the kitchen if anyone was going to come andbring menus and weight on us. A huffy waitress finally came out and kind of apologized. After that it took nearly 20 minutes forappetizers and then another 20 for our meals. We were literally the only ones seated in the main part of the place. My husbandliked his carbonara but the penne dish I got was nothing as described. The sauce was flavorless and runny. The chicken wascompletely undercooked. In any other situation I would have sent it back but we had already waited so long and my kids weregetting antsy. There are many other much better Italian places in Louisville to eat that have great customer service. I wouldnot return to this one. I wish I had paid more attention to the reviews posted before mine. Our experience does not seem unique.This place feels like they are doing you a big favor by doing their jobs and waiting on you. And we were nice and courteous evenafter being ignored. Skip this one. Read more

Every meal I’ve had at Milantoni has been excellent. Just left dinner with my wife. Two wonderful entrees, live violinist,... wine, and limoncello. Remodeled to perfection. Ignore any bad reviews…they simply are wrong. Don’t worry about the lackof a real entrance from Hurstbourne. This place is a pleasant surprise every single time. Reasonable prices as well. Read more

One of my absolute favorite Friday night haunts! Never disappoints. They have a violinist who plays while you eat on Friday... nights he is wonderful..The have recently remodeled and it is looking fantastic. The food is always amazing. The fettuccine andred sauce both are top notch. So any dish you have from chicken to seafood to pizza are great. The staff are always friendly andhelpful! We return again and again. My family loves this.place! ?? Read more

Good sized portion for the cost. Everything was nice and hot. Nice little local shop as an alternative option from driving... really far for some place bigger. Read more

We love this place! Its great for lunch and dinner family or date night food is amazing and love the sangria! Must try!

The server we had seemed to be very inexperienced, however with some potential. The server was very polite and pleasant.... Calzone was very large and good tasting. Although my wife's salad and meal came out at the same time and she was about halfway through her meal before mine came out. Read more

WOW... Great food.. this place has a very cozy atmosphere.. good staff.. and for a small place wait time wasn't bad.. The... food... BIG portions.. you won't leave hungry.. I had the fettuccine Alfredo (pictured) my partner had calzon also pictured...Again for a Saturday night The wait wasn't bad... And promise it's well worth the wait Read more

Outside appearance does not compare to the experience inside! Brittany (sorry if I spelled your name wrong) greeted, seated and... waited on my husband and me promptly. We ordered the Bruschetta de Milantoni as our appetizer, which was the perfect texture andso tasty. Our entrees included Catalina Florentine (suggested to me by “B” when I told her what I was deciding between), andMediterraneo. Both dishes were served hot, in good time, and we were blown away by portion size and how delicious they were; mymouth is still watering! Not only did my husband and I have leftovers from our entrees, we ordered a Cannoli and 16” WhitePizza Pie (w/o tomatoes) to go! What a delightful establishment- quaint and friendly with mood setting Italian music playing inthe background. We will DEFINITELY be back! Read more