Reviews for Sicilian Pizza & Pasta Glenmary Plaza in Louisville, KY

Let me first start off and say me and my wife are long time customers and absolutely loved this place. Unfortunately the last... few times we have been, we started noticing it has started to go downhill. The service has been a little rough and food has notbeen as tasty. I understand this happens at restaurants and we have tried to give the benefit of the doubt hoping this wouldimprove. But last night my wife ordered a pizza with pineapple on it and it tasted bad. The pineapple tasted old. She picked itoff and ate around it and we just let them know about it, not to complain but to inform them and suggest to throw away thatpineapple so no one else got it. Several hours later my wife got food poisoning and got pretty sick. We are pretty certain itwas from the pineapple. Although we will probably not visit again for a long time after that one. I just wanted to let you knowthis place was once great and I hope you are able to bring it back to what it once was. It's sad to watch great restaurantsdeterate. Please know we are hoping you are able to get things back together. P.S. I hope you threw away that pineapple as it ismostly likely rancid and dangerous at this point. Thank you. Read more

Pizza is my favorite to get but I also love the Calzones, Stromboli and the salads. Always great food and atmosphere. ... Definitely recommend sitting out on their new patio area as it?s started to cool down too! Read more

We order once a week, same order every time. Always a medium Calzone. Got a pretty sketchy small. When I called I was on hold 10... minutes before I just gave up. I know you?re short handed, but I drive along way every week because it?s our favorite. Read more

We have always considered their pizza to be some of the best. However, our carryout pizza that we bought yesterday wasn't. We... ordered a large supreme and the toppings were extremely scarce! We are SO disappointed and won't be back. Read more

Friendly staff, delicious food! Great atmosphere and deals. Wait wasn't too long and the staff was really fast with our meal and... dessert! We'll be back. Read more

I used to love this place but now its kind of a joke.. i feel they're really cutting corners.. in no way should these little... niblet wings be the price they are. We were joking & comparing who had the smallest wing. I should have just gotten someMcNuggets and called it a day.. maybe then would i have been full. (Wing size of a quarter In picture) Read more

As you know if you read my last review, I am in Louisville at least once a month and every time I land, the Sicilian is my go to... dinner spot the first night. I ordered the Sicilian with added mushrooms, and I don?t know that I have ever been more pleasedwith a pizza in my life!!! I mean, every time is amazing, but this time they simply out did themselves. So amazing, and again,the crust is delicious. I never eat the ?pizza bones? at the end of the slice, but I devour these every time ? no sauce needed.Do yourself a favor and hit this place when you are down on 4th. It is the best treat you could give yourself!!! Read more

The Sicilian is pretty good. Not my favorite pizza I've very had, but pretty good and I would go back. The house dressing... tastes like off brand ranch and the cheesy garlic bread is really just a cheese pizza. The cheese raviolis are in a casserolestyle, so they are pretty much just cheese manicotti. The pizza was good (I got the ultimate supreme which is $2 more). Theprices aren't too bad (small pizza is $10.99). The atmosphere is actually pretty great with sports on the TVs, plenty ofseating, and a very friendly staff. This is our first pizza place in Louisville, but it definitely won't be our last. It isworth trying out, especially if you want to go for a more local place instead of a chain restaurant. Read more