Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Macedon, NY
Glad there is pizza in Macedon. Stopped by for lunch on a Tuesday. There was a backlog of orders, but the people behind the... counter got it done swiftly. Reasonable wait time. In and out in under 20 minutes. I ended up with a slice, wings, and a brew.Took it to a local park for better scenery. Macedon is great, but terrible infrastructure in the canal town by Lock 30.Salvatore's is located in a very desolate and empty part of town. Location not great, but the inside is clean and wellmaintained. Read more
Never again.. Ordered online. sheet pizza 40 wings ($112). Call to confirm they got it and everything was right.. Guy says 25-35... mins... Sweet. I leave Palmyra 20 mins later and head there. Walk in pizza is coming out of oven. Perfect.. guy checks on mywings. Comes back. Oh sorry sir the girl doing wings can't read and only dropped 20 instead of 40. So we sit there for almost30mins. Pizza is cold 1st order of wings are getting cold. Guy comes up with other wings and says sir you're all set. Ilaughed and said I want the manager... He states he was. So his solution to the problem is give me $20 back on my card.Whatever I'll take it. The girl who can't read the ticket is standing there giving me dirty looks... Like I did something wrong.No no girly you did. Not me. So we get back home to my sons 2nd birthday party and we enjoyed cold pizza and wings. Neveragain macedon salvators. It'll close soon anyways they never last long there. Read more
$30 for a slice and a sub the sub is watered down package meat and $6 for delivery charge lol some companies soaked that covid... up never go there again and food sucked Read more
I came for lunch a couple of guys and tried the Eggplant Dish, waited a few minutes but it was worth the wait;... delicious! Amazing food not just the delish pizza moreover, the guys that run the place are on top of their game and are superfriendly, definitely recommended ???????? Read more
I ordered a fish fry and steak sandwich and by the time it finally got to me it was cold. The funny thing is the Mac salad was... warm and everything else was cold. Not to mention, I was charged for steak sauce that I never received and a $5 delivery chargeafter waiting an hour and a half for delivery. Called to see if it was on the way and was told, " we only have 1 driver itshould be there soon". Ok I get that alot of places are short-handed but if you can't provide the service due to that, thendon't do it. Needless to say, very disappointed Read more
This Salvatore's is very tasty and is better than Mark's all day long. However I believe the younger staff needs to be trained a... bit more. I got breaded wings that were very clumped with breading. I ate the wings but not without tearing alot of the wingsapart so I could find the meat. Read more
So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old... fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum! Read more
We ordered a pan pizza and 10 boneless wings for them to goto a wrong address and then leave and not say a thing so we call them... and they were so rude about it and when we told them the right address they couldn?t even find our trailer which is sad becauseshe barely looked for it. Everything was cold and we got sick from the food. Why hire people that don?t care!! Read more