Reviews for Ryba's Fudge Shop - Cornerstore in Mackinac Island, MI

Friendly service and best fudge I ever had! I tried the famous ?original? Murdicks across the street and boy, what a... disappointment! Rude service, fudge hard as a rock and ultimately rather grainy. Rybas was the real deal! Nice staff, freshfudge, so creamy! Wouldn?t go anywhere else on the island for fudge, Im a Rybas loyalist! Read more

Sad. Took our two nephews in for ice cream at 7:25pm last night. The two you do ladies running the shop refused to give us two... ice cream cones because they had ?already washed there utensils?. If they were not serving they should have locked their doorsand closed early. They would rather have two disappointed kids. Bad service. Thank goodness Sanders across the street tookcare of us. Much nicer staff anyway ! Read more

Oh my goodness. Everything about this place is AMAZING!!! I had the strawberry pecan fudge and let me just say, that was the... best fudge I?ve had in my entire life! The fudge was creamy, rich, sweet but not too sweet. I was like a dream! Then we got theice cream and oh my goodness!!!!!! That was the best ice cream I?ve had in my life. You could tell it was homemade and it was socreamy and delicious!!!! This place is HIGHLY recommend by me and my 6 person family. (my brother liked the fudge so much he atean entire bar in one night, he said he stomach hurt so bad but it was worth it.) Read more

Really cute fudge shop with pink interior. The smell that wafts through near the door is amazing! You can watch them make the... fudge on granite slabs and ask for free samples! They also have pecan turtles, English toffee and salt water taffy sold by thebag or bucket. The flavor of the fudge is amazing!! It's extremely fresh and light, and the best thing is that the flavor is nottoo overpowering or strong. It feels like a very light and smooth taste, and not super sweet. "Chocolate no nut" and "Peanutbutter" are some of their popular flavors. Read more

The smell of fudge is enticing wherever you walk on Main St. It?s ok, but if you tout a 60 year old business I would expect a 60... year old recipe. Corn syrup? Vegetable oil? Powdered milk? Shame it doesn?t even taste or have the mouthfeel like fudge. And atthat price! I wish I could return it I feel that strongly about it but I can?t so I want others to warned what they are payinga premium price for. Read more

I ended up buying 2 slices of Fudge, a Rocky Road and Chocolate Peanut Butter while visiting Mackinac Island. These were some of... the best flavors of Fudge I have ever had. When we visit again I will definitely be buying these and maybe an additional slice. Read more

Our whole family was looking forward to experiencing Mackinac Island fudge. We visited several stores, but this one was clearly... the winner for allergy concerns. They did an excellent job of accommodating my wife's Celiac diagnosis, and the employee wasknowledgeable about the diagnosis and the process and could explain what options would be best. On top of that, the fudge waslighter and creamier than some of the other shops. We loved it! Read more

Paid $20 for 2 ice cream cones and got so little ice cream and it wasn?t even that good. It was $6.50 I believe for 1 scoop and... $3 for an additional scoop. Does that image look like 2 scoops? It was ridiculous. Don?t Go there. Read more