Reviews for Mackinaw Pastie & Cookie Co. in Mackinaw City, MI

While the original got me hooked, the Pastie Stroganoff is now my staple. So much so, I have to order them by the dozen and have... them shipped to me. Read more

All the pasties are exactly the same but some have a gross sauce. Ick!!!

A must go to place for your pasties! Buy one hot and wrapped to walk around with, then buy some frozen to go home with you.... Great staff! Try the original, chicken and especially the breakfast pastie. YUM! Read more

I didn't get to try their pasties because they were super expensive, but from what i gather, people enjoy them, I did notice the... restaurant was clean, and the staff was friendly. If I had a chance to try their food, I probably would of given more stars.Maybe someday I'll update this review! Read more

We enjoy our pasty lunch at Mackinaw Pastie & Cookie Company every year on our visit to Mackinaw City. The staff always makes... sure that my family has a nice visit. For instance they don't pressure us to get beverages, although they have nice fountaindrinks. We usually just get cups of water and we're happy! Thanks! Read more

Friendly service. Very good pasties. We got the breakfast one and also tried the beef. Have to say it was one of the top two... meals we had locally. Definitely worth going here! Read more

My first pastie experience was a great one. Went with the stroganoff topping (gravy, sour cream, and chives) and loved it!... Service was very friendly as well. Read more

Went to try my first pastie. Got the meal so we got a cookie and cole slaw. The pastie was unremarkable as was the cookie. ... Loved the slaw! My wife doesn't like slaw, so I was glad to eat hers. My wife thought the cookie was good. Loved the gasfireplace when it was 40 degrees outside. Read more