Reviews for Amish Creamery Co in Madeira Beach, FL
The ice cream was very tasty and a good selection to choose from. The serving size was also impressive. Also, they had lots of... other items for sale like jellies, etc. Last but not least the woman behind the counter was very friendly. We will be back forsure! Read more
Delicious Icecream & Very friendly staff! We will definitely be back. I had the pecan praline and it was the best I've ever had!... Thank you for the great service & amazing icecream. Read more
The customer service is Amazing! Everything is fresh and locally made. I couldn?t decide between all the flavors. I picked... pistachio which was great and was torn between banana walnut crunch and sea-salt caramel. They ended up giving me a small scoopof the caramel seeing I was having a hard time deciding. It was so sweet! We drove from Clearwater to this place. It?s worth it! Read more
Go here! Skip the lines on Gulf Blvd for scrumptious, homemade ice cream and other goods. Tons of flavors, loved the waffle cone... bowls! Cheese curds, horseradish, meats, jams, jellies, honey, spices/rubs, popcorn, pickles, eggs, canned veggies/fruits,noodles, candy and so much more! Brought to you by the Sarasota Amish/Mennonite community, including Northern imports from Ohioand Wisconsin (including Der Dutchman, Walnut Creek and more). Bring a cooler and stock up! You'll be hooked! Read more
100% recommended. Super clean place. Ice cream is delicious, not very sweet, just right amount of sugar. And our daughter has... lactose intolerance , she even found a perfect dairy free ice cream for her. Read more
Excellent ice cream - if you don?t have a go-to flavor, plan extra time to ponder the options. The sorbet is very flavorful - we... tried mango. Mudslide and peanut butter cup were a terrific combo! Read more
Best ice-cream in Madeira Beach!! For anyone from the Midwest...they have Super(man)Hero!! I had the superhero and the cotton... candy...super yummy!! It's Amish ice-cream, so it's extra creamy and delicious!! The owner is so kind!! We had a great timechatting with him!! Read more
So good and the flavors actually have flavor, like real flavor not that fake weird perfume taste! This trip we opted for a... chocolate and banana pudding and they were both pure perfection. We have tried a lot of the other flavors as well? I thought Iremembered them having seasonal items, but haven?t been noticing that recently. Pricing wasn?t bad either compared to otherplaces locally. Read more