Reviews for Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery in Madison, NJ
We went for dinner at Romanellis last night to support a local organization (they do a ton of these fundraisers for local... groups) and I had a fan favorite - the Caesar salad - and my daughter had the penne Vodka. The best thing about the Caesar arethe croutons - made from breadsticks! And my kids would eat the penne vodka every day if they had the chance. Finally ifyou’re craving a pie, be sure to try the square grandma’s version- it’s definitely one of my favorites in the area. Read more
Oh, these people do great Italian dinners. Pizza is good but it's all about the sausage and peppers, chicken cutlets, and all... the dinner entrees. We come from Chatham and pass about 5 other pizza joints on our way here because nobody does it likeRomanelli's Read more
My first time there. The pizza was more of a little kids size and flimsy. The sauce was good and the crust was crunchy which... gives it the 3 stars. Read more
Went to this place countless times since I was a kid. Just a solid high-quality pizza place and Jersey style Italian food. My... only complaint is that if you get used to the type of high quality NJ pizza like they make here, if you ever leave the state(like I did) it will be almost impossible for you to like the local "attempts" at pizza. Hope these guys stick around forever. Read more
We frequent romanellis but recently ordered a lot of pies for my sons birthday party. Multiple people specifically told me it... was great pizza and everyone is from NJ so you know it’s good Read more
Wow!!! It has been a long time since I ordered from Romanelli's. What awesome pies!!!!! We got a margherita pie with pepperoni,... and a spinach pie. Totally hit the spot. Romanelli's will become a bad habit for me this summer........lol Read more
Scouting Morris County Pizza for the Pizza Hunters App and ended up at Romanellis Pizza. Now this place is a prime example of... how a restaurant has been in business for 50 years and they rest on their laurels and don't produce what I am sure was greatPizza at one point. I have to be honest, the pepperoni slice that was presented was not good. I should give 1star, but out ofrespect, I am chalking it up to. Bad day. It was all grease, thin slice that flopped, no sauce with little cheese. VeryDisappointed, was expecting a lot more for 50 years. The server was nice, and outdoor seating was fantastic. Cannot speak onother pasta dishes, only Pizza. Read more
I’ve been going to Romanelli’s for quite a few years now. Solid pizza, AWESOME service and staff, and overall and incredible... place to get a good slice. Read more