Reviews for Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. in Madison, NJ
I have to say that even if in the past they had good ( not exceptional) pizza, this time they managed to hit the bottom of the... bottom. In my life I have had pizza from everywhere but this one was tasteless, half poorly cooked like they piled up a hugelayer on mozzarella on top of mushroom that tasted like the had been poured from a jar not even cooked, the mozzarella wasbarely melted , seems like they pre cooked the crust threw some topping on it with no flavor and barely reheated it. It was barnone, the WORST pizza I have ever eaten. And for 37 dollars( I had the chicken appetizer, seems they have also compromised onthe quality of the meat) it is really way too much. I will stop ordering Read more
I called the Madison location, I asked about our delivery order, from toast tab. For whatever reason the toast tab app switched... the order from delivery to pick up. The manager was so nice and polite on the phone, and apologized. To accommodate us, hedropped it off personally at our house. What service! What a nice caring young man! We absolutely love their fresh made pasta,fioro di zucca, and the most wonderful salads. I would highly recommend this restaurant. One of our favorite places. Read more
We were advised by our BNB to go to Tino's. Boy were they right. The food was amazing. The chicken Bites and the Sicilian Pie... highly recommended. Read more
Food was very good. Ceasar salad was a little light on dressing but was very good. Croutons taste homemade, it was very fresh... and crispy and the cheese was very good quality and super tasty. The pizza was excellent but I thought a bit pricey for thesize. We did split both the salad and the pizza for our lunch and I did bring home 2 slices of pizza but it is a bit of an oddsize. Too much for one and a bit small to share. Not sure what you would do if you were dining alone. And at $17 it's not apersonal pie price especially for a lunch. I would definitely go back as the food was good. Table next to us got chicken parmand that looked good also. Not sure if they requested it that way but there was not any pasta served with it. Read more
Our family has been friends and fans of Tino's for decades since Kingston and when we moved to the Madison area we were excited... to have our favorite pizza right here, locally! We wanted to celebrate our move with a housewarming party and asked Tino if hecould cater for 40 kids and adults with our favorite dishes! We've catered multiple times from Kingston, Jersey City and nowMadison---everything is always consistent and seamless. Our guests had a blast and raved about the food! I am so glad that I cansave myself stress while entertaining large groups and leave the cooking to the pros! Thank you Tino's! Read more
Wonderful! I had lunch with my husband at Tino's. First time since changed hands 2 years ago. I have to say we really enjoyed... this place! They had a lunch special, Margherita pizza and 1/2 salad of choice. The pizza was delicious! We chose the Grecosalad. The half portion was very generous and tasty. We had to have the octopus also (nice and lemony). Sam took very goodcare of us! I recommend. Read more
Honestly, I can't say I was excited for another pizza place in Madison. Let the record state, I was wrong. Tino's is a very... welcome addition to the Madison family of restaurants! The dough is light and airy, but also crispy on the bottom. Random tip-- be sure to eat there to fully enjoy the experience -- the crust isn't as crispy once you reach home) The ingredients are veryfresh and absolutely delicious. We've since been back...three times. Read more
Excellent pizza. Perfectly cooked. Loved margarita and the zucchini pizza. Really like that they have sourdough crust! Will go... again. Read more