Loading

Reviews for Tony Boys Sandwich House in Madison, NJ

Jeff Rezz 1 year ago
5

I come here almost every day for lunch and get the same thing most of the time. Dan, the owner, is one of the reasons that sets... this place apart and above other places in town. He makes you feel special because he not only knows me by name but alsoremembers my order. You can tell that he cares about his product and his people. He is constantly smiling and upbeat. He isalways cleaning every table right after the customer leaves and making sure everyone is happy. I've tried a few things here,but my two favorites are 'The Dip' and the 'Lumpy'. My favorite side is by far the 'Hand Cut Fries'. They are easily the bestfries in Madison. And last but not least are the drinks...they have their own sodas! My favorite is the Vanilla Soda. One ofthese days I will be courageous and try their Meatloaf special. Read more

Greg Parys 1 year ago
5

Love this place. Cutlet sandwiches are the best. My favorite is the West Coast. The avocado and chicken always taste so fresh. ... Can?t wait to try the whole menu. Read more

Vince Piotti 1 year ago
5

Hands down the best sandwich spot in Madison. We order there weekly and had an event catered. Can?t go wrong with the entire... menu. Read more

Cory Johnston 1 year ago
5

Yeah, this place is the real deal. Fantastic turkey sub. Will be returning soon to try a chicken cutlet sandwich.

Sean O'Connor 1 year ago
5

Ordering Tony Boy's delivery has become a weekly staple in my house. I'm not someone who will typically order a salad, but my... go-to is the chop chop sandwich with eggplant and Caesar dressing. It's basically a monster Caesar salad with thin, crispyeggplant on a sub roll. And it's incredible. We've tried a few other sammies and eat happily every time. Thank goodness theydeliver all the way to Randolph, as there are no decent sub spots left out this way. Don't miss the fries or the vodka sauce,both are great. Read more

Sarah Manfredo 1 year ago
4

My husband and I had Tony Boys delivered after returning from a long trip in the car. I had the roast beef sub and he had the... lumpy chicken sandwich. My husband thought the lumpy was excellent, and even though it's not my thing, the bite I tried wastasty. I was happy with the roast beef, it was rare as promised on the menu. My only complaint was that the sub roll was hard. Iattribute that to us placing an order late in the day. As a true sandwich lover, it was disappointing, but I'm definitely opento giving Tony Boys another try. We definitely appreciated the affordable and speedy delivery. Read more

Tev W 2 years ago
5

Addendum: I received a call from the owner and was made aware the employee wasn?t supposed to charge me for anything, due to it... being a store credit based order. The owner, Dan, assured me I?ll be refunded and the situation was rectified. I appreciate theprompt response and great customer service provided to me by the owner. I?ll be ordering from there again in the nearfuture. This place is a joke. I received a store credit, as a result of a mistake they made with a previous order placed, andwas given a store credit for another sandwich to be delivered to me free of charge. Once, I utilized the store credit, I wasthen charged a delivery fee. How is that justifiable? I then raised my issue with that and was told all deliveries are charged afee, even orders paid for with store credit, including my situation. I?ll never order from them again. Read more

Nicaluz Raagas 2 years ago
4

First time ordering from here and it wasn?t a bad deal. On uber they had a buy one get one special? so I opted in for a very... basic turkey and cheese. The packaging was sustainable, and the meats and condiments are fresh. The bread, on the other hand Ijust didn?t like.. it?s the hard bread; which is subjective but just isn?t for me. Read more