Reviews for Brothers Three Bar & Grill in Madison, WI
My wife ordered a burger Well done which is stated on the receipt but the inside was pink and raw in the center. I ordered a... steak which was cooked correctly but the meat was very grisly. The mashed potatoes were cold and very bland tasting. When webrought the problem to the server's attention she took the food but never offered to cook the burger over. Very disappointedthat she paid for food she didn't eat. We always try to support local places when traveling. Read more
Came with a group of 9, and sat outside for dinner. Our server was friendly and food was good. I?d recommend any of the burgers!
Used to be the best fish fry I've ever had, pandemic hit and haven't been back since before the remodel. It's just as... incredible as I was hoping, they kept their portions, they kept the quality, prices went up but that's fine as the service andfood didn't go down. Their fish is so fresh and juicy it's almost like they have their own lake in the back they're catchingfish from. If you've never been here, absolutely get their garlic mashed potatoes, OMG just inject them into my VEINS! Read more
Definitely not the Brothers Three of old. Modern hot spot for great breakfast/brunch and drinks. The food is just as good as... it's ever been and the environment is a lot more inclusive now. Only thing that has really suffered is the wait times. Make itin before 10 to keep it to a minimum. Luckily bar spots usually open up quick and the excellent drinks will keep you busy till atable opens up. Service can be slow, but they do their best and the staff is super friendly. Read more
They didn't get our online takeout order automatically. Instead, I got an email from ToastTab telling me to call the restaurant... because they hadn't acknowledged the order. When I called the restaurant, they apologized and got the order started, but I hadto wait around for about 15 extra minutes. They did apologize, and they did get our order entirely correct, including a massivenumber of individually packed sauces! They also did a great job of separating out the hot and cold, including separating theburgers from the buns/lettuce/tomatoes/pickles, which was nice. Good quality bar food, especially the onion rings and bonelesswings. Fried pickles were actually pickle fries, which was kinda cool (but maybe would be better fresh, in restaurant). Friedcod fish fry was ok (probably should have gone for perch or bluegill). Cheese curds and fries were standard (good enough). Baconcheeseburger was good (not great), but cooked perfectly. Overall really satisfying meal, but nothing too special. Read more
Amazing food. We've been in town for 5 days and have eaten here twice. Once for dinner and once for breakfast. Has delicious... food and good service both times. The prime rib steak and eggs is some of the best steak ive ever had. Read more
Visited on a Thursday night. Inside was cozy, and we were able to snag the back corner both which gave off a wonderful secluded... vibe. I had the meatloaf, which was super flavorful and moist. I swapped my potatoes out for green beans which were alsofantastic. The beans were cooked perfectly (not mush) and still had the tiniest bit of snap to them. Out server was superattentive, but not annoying which is the goldie-locks zone for restaurant service. Well defiantly be back again! ???? Read more
Brunch actually ends at 130. Good corner spot. I'm a local so a bit biased, but brunch is always stellar. Patio is great in... the warmer months. Fish fry is also spot on. Never had bad service. Never too crowded to get a spot (maybe in big game days). Many tvs to watch sports and a few "slot machines". Not a dingy dive but also nothing over the top decor wise. Read more