Reviews for Casetta Kitchen and Counter in Madison, WI

Casetta Kitchen and Counter serves really good sandwiches made with high quality ingredients and they are packed with flavor. We... wish that they were open for more than just lunches on week days, making them hard to fit into a full time work schedule butthey are worth going on days off. One gripe is that they run out of ingredients so if you go later in the day they may be out oftheir daily specials. Read more

Seriously one of the best sandwiches I have had in a LONG time! Had the Italian and added some fresh mozzarella. It was... perfection! The hot peppers had just the right kick. Ordering and pick up was a breeze. They had a few tables outside forseating otherwise it?s carry out only right now. 5 stars! 10/10! Read more

Great spot for a quick lunch! The foccacia was particularly delicious (Paul Hollywood would be impressed!) and the flavors of... the different sandwich options were interesting, flavorful, and just plain tasty. The roast beef was shaved really thinly withgreat color and texture. Didn't get to try the cookies because they ran out on an especially busy day, but they looked amazingand I'd love to go back someday! Read more

Sandwiches are fairly priced for the size and quality - not cheap, not expensive, and definitely worth it. Focaccia bread is... soft, chewy, and flavorful. The Italian is a great sandwich! A generous helping of cured meats balanced with spicy peppers,lettuce, and tomato. Casetta stays busy, but for good reason. You'll be rewarded for your wait. These sandwiches arespectacular. Read more

LOVED the turkey sandwich - added aioli and the flavor combos were fresh yet classic. The focaccia bread was perfect and highly... recommend dining in. Italian was something special as well - salty Italian meats with cool, refreshing dressing on focaccia isa tasty sandwich. The Monday Meatball on a hero roll is also great, got it to go for dinner later and it reheatedwell. Eclectic beverage variety also a plus. Read more

Go for the creative and delicious sandwiches, keep going back for the specials and never forget to grab a cookie?if they still... have them. There?s a lot of love and care that goes into everything they make. They use top quality meat that is sliced freshbefore it is placed between their outstanding bread. With most sandwiches you can choose between hero and focaccia. They?re bothphenomenal, but my preference is the focaccia. Make sure to follow them on Instagram, so you know what specials are coming up.Be sure to give the spicy chickpeas a try and their soups look delicious. They also offer take home dinners that I haven?ttried, but I can guarantee are amazing. And the cookies, oh the cookies. If you get there past noon, they are probably soldout. There?s only one kind, chocolate chip, but it will change your life. They are soft with ribbons of chocolate and big flakysalt on top for a sweet and salty combination that will make your mouth water. Read more

I had them cater a training for my work today - it was great! Everything was simple and arrived right on time. They had a great... variety and most of the attendees had never had their sandwiches before until now. I will definitely be ordering from themagain! Read more

Absolutely amazing! My favorite sandwich is the Paradigm on focaccia bread. Also love the Sullivan, the Italian, and the... chocolate chip cookies. It's my dream to figure out how they swirl in the chocolate like that. Read more