Reviews for Benvenuto's in Mahopac, NY
Food is always delicious! I love the welcoming atmosphere - you feel like family dining here.
Amazing pizza, pasta and service. Lots of options. Friendly staff. Uff everything you need to enjoy a great Italian meal.
I've never had a bad meal here whether it's take out or eat in. The chicken scarpiello is by far the best scarp in the area .... Very friendly staff and excellent service. Highly recommend stopping in and getting yourself something to eat. Read more
Food was good. However. the prices on the bill were higher than those on the menu.
BE CAREFUL WHEN ORDERING OFF THEIR ONLINE MENU!!! Was charged more than the prices on their online menu and was never given a... side salad and side pasta with my dinner entree. Called restaurant, spoke with owner. He said the dinner I ordered was the ONLYONE that didn't come with a side pasta & salad. I explained that the website said ALL dinner entrees come with one, alsomentioned we were overcharged. He said the website hasnt been updated in 3 years, refused to honor the menu online and give mewhat the dinner came with and would not honor the websites prices. The OWNER cursed at me on the phone and hung up on me. NEVERAGAIN WILL I ORDER FROM HERE. Read more
Stopped in the other day for a slice. Absolutely amazing pizza. So many choices to choose from. The Chicken Bacon Ranch was... delicious. Portion sizes are large and great price. Two massive slices of pizza and a drink for $10. Highly recommend thisestablishment for a great slice. Will update review after trying their catering, have heard really good things. Read more
This is my grandmother's favorite place and our family has come here for years, good pizza, good Italian dishes, and specials... that are wonderfully diverse and rich with flavor. The portions are no joke and the prices here can't be beat. The wineselection is good, only good quality vinos. Hospitality is A+, you must try it out! Read more
Loved the pizza but asked for 2 orders of garlic knots and I think they warmed them up from the previous day. They were... definitely not fresh. Dry and crumbly???? Read more