Reviews for Sonny & Tony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Mahwah, NJ

Love the food here,friendly staffand can bring the family here plus inexpensive. Update just went back here last night ... food is so good love the pizza.update just had a delivery from here got a personal pizza with extra cheese it arrived on time and it was in perfect condition the cheese didn't slide off the pizza .When I get it at other places always find it is a mess cheese all over the place except the pie.Great job Sonn and Tony's a the delivery man. Read more

Buon appetito ? A place you ought to visit whenever you have time ?

Friendly service but Noting Hill to everything else ! The delivery time was just way too long. It took over an hour for one... item. The sausage personal pie was not the best , not the worse but also not for me! Read more

Food is always hot & delicious!!! Their wings are the BEST. I also love their chicken caesar wrap and their margherita pizza!... Just a few of my favorites. Totally recommended. Read more

Update September 2022: Without warning they stopped honoring and participating in the pizza points on the slice app. However,... you still need to order the pizza off slice and pay the local fees without any benefit. Unfortunately I have 7 pizza points andneeded one more for a free pizza. I accepted that they needed to raises prices on their menu and I continued to order, but thisis one more way to alienate and be cheap towards loyal customers. You’ve lost my business of purchasing weekly, what a shame,but shame on you. Pizza is the best I’ve had in this area. The wings are very good but could be sauced a little more. Garlicknots are tasty. The speed of the takeout can get a little long at times but the staff are friendly and work hard. Read more

Pizza was average, garlic knots not so great, mozzarella sticks tasted store bough and or 12 dollars, not worth it. We dined in... and waited for 30min for a cheese pizza and Ceasars salad, tables next to us came after and got their food first. Dissapointingfamily experience. My kids were not happy. Another pizza place off the list. Read more

Just okay. I liked the bread. Portions were large but taste and quality very average. The woman who answered the phone was... cheerful and helpful. We got penne arribiata...spicy and too huge to finish. Also clam linguini...expensive dry and not sotasty. Might want to look around for a different place. Read more

They made it very festive inside for the holidays. The servers checked on us all the time. Made the visit personal. The food was... absolutely delicious. Even have some for leftovers. The dessert was exactly what I needed. The manager were soo friendly. If youare ever in the Mahwah area you must go to Sonny & Tony. Read more