Reviews for SQ Pizza in Mahwah, NJ
Ordered 2 BBQ, 1 buffalo and 1 chicken parm. When we got home we noticed it was 1 BBQ and 2 buffalo - called the store and they... gave us a free slice on them next time. All of the slices were bomb although we could have gotten away with just 2 slicesinstead of 4 since they were LOADED with chicken & they were huge. Will for sure be back again soon!! Happy to have found a goodplace nearby for pizza after Davincis closed. Read more
Pizza was pretty good for the style of pizza it is, plenty of meat on the meat lovers and the Margherita had a decent flavor,... the pizza reheated well the next day. I would not recommend getting the buffalo wings delivered by the time they got to me thebreading was falling off of them, they may be better in store so I wouldn't discount them completely. All in all its worth ashot its just a different pizza. Read more
This is a follow-up. This time I got delivery. Just like the first time I picked up in-store, the pizza was delicious. (We... like the traditional round pie with several toppings). The delivery driver was in uniform and very friendly. I felt like I wasin a comnercial, (a good thing). Five stars all-around! Keep up the good work. Read more
Unexpected gem off the highway. As an italian I?m really really impressed by the quality of their pizza. From now on I will stop... there every time I need to go to NYC. Not that easy to find a well done Roman style square pizza. Well done! Read more
I ordered this for my clients for lunch today. I ordered several random things for them. For myself I ordered the veggiewich... pizza sandwich minus the cheese. I asked the restaurant to separate my food and they did just that. The food arrived on time andmy clients enjoyed it. It came to a little over $100 with delivery fee and tip. When I got the chance to dig in it was good. Inever had a sandwich like this before and even without cheese it was still tasty. All in all I had a good experience. Read more
SQ Pizza is the best pizza in the area hands down! The pizza crust is tasty, crisp, and the pizza is huge! My personal favorite... pie is the Margarita but I have yet to try a pizza I did not like! They are just off the highway in a nice plaza and are prettyquick. If you want good pizza this is the place to go! Read more
Nice change of pace from the typical pizza joint. The crust here is the biggest difference ? as advertised, it?s light, airy and... very tasty and you can choose between the end and middle slices when ordering (some slices, being square, have more crust thanothers). A nice variety of toppings / speciality slices plus a menu that includes sandwiches, salads and traditional round pies.I ordered a few different slices to try and they all came out quickly. I wouldn?t say any of the slices had a lot of sauce orcheese, though ? they were good but I prefer more of both, personally. Indoor dining features socially-distanced tables, handsanitizer by the entrance, a TV and contactless payment options (as of Jan. 2021). Read more
Amazing pizza! Especially the crust. Love the honesty about their ingredients. Only suggestions would be to add more sauce to... compliment the crust, using a local cheese vendor (jersey girl cheese) for mozzarella, and having garlic powder available nextto the grated parm. Will be back and hope for more sauce ! Read more