Reviews for Pegasus I Restaurant in Malaga, NJ
Horrible take-out experience!! Ordered take-out on June 2022. Chicken Francaise to be precise. When I got home, I didn't... realize that the sauce had spilled all over my car seat because the staff had not sealed the container properly. I called theestablishment to speak with the manager and there was none. So I explain to a young lady what had happened & her response wasthat these things happen when you order take out at any place. Yes, go figure!!?? When I told them that I was not happy becausemy dinner was ruined and that my car seat had stains. The girl in charge was quick to judge and told me that they couldn'tdetail my car. In the first place, I had not asked for that. All I wanted was that my situation be corrected since I had nomeal. As I waited for a response, they told me the manager would call me back the next day. They didn't call. So, I had tocall them back 2 days later. When I called the manager asked me what happened and then said that the next meal would be onthem. She took my name, my phone number and my address. I came back 3 months later, placed my order and drove for about 30miles; so they could tell me that they remembered me but they couldn't find there slip and couldn't give me my meal!! I was andstill angry because they had me drive a long distance to tell me this!! I have eaten at this place for many years, never had acomplaint and the manager was aware of this. I will NEVER come to this place again. Such poor customer service!! Manager &staff should take a course on customer service & satisfaction. And don't be surprised if your place goes out of business. ThePrestige Diner in Vineland is #1 in customer satisfaction, their menu has a wide selection to chose from and their meals arerelatively priced accordingly. Read more
Best restaurant in the area, good prices and specials. Very clean and nice decor. You will get your money's worth and have an... enjoyable meal. Read more
ALL the employees are very friendly!!???????????? The food is great and the service is quick!! The restaurant is clean and... inviting. The prices ARE reasonable. The desserts they have there look SO amazing and yummy I wanted to pick one up after we hadbreakfast!! I HIGHLY recommend if you're in the Malaga, NJ area, you definitely should stop at the Pegasus Diner/Restaurant!! ToALL the employees, keep up the GREAT WORK!!???????????? Read more
Loved the food! Had a knowledgeable, friendly & professional waitress named Emily. Keep up the good work. One Request: Please... can you eliminate using red peppers in so many dishes you serve Please! I will be a return customer! Read more
I have been to Pegasus a number of times with my husband and been pleased with the food and the service until yesterday. A... server spilled an entire ice tea on me. Never apologized, never offered a towel to me. Was only interested in cleaning thefloor. Food was good but they don't care about customers. Read more
I had an overall excellent experience at this restaurant. The service was fantastic and the price point was exceptional! The... quality of the food was magnificent, and the portions were larger than I expected. I ordered CHICKEN PICANTE: Chicken BreastLightly Coated in Gluten-Free Flour, Sautéed in Virgin Olive Oil, Sliced Mushrooms, Capers, White Wine, Lemon, and ButterPicante Sauce. My friend ordered STEAK & EGGS, 12oz N.Y. Strip Steak, Three Eggs Any Style, Home Fries & Toast Read more
Great breakfast specials if you arrive before 11am for $9.99 or less. Our food was hot and the coffee was good. Good breakfast... selection. We all enjoyed our food and got a full plate! Nice bright atmosphere. Good service and waitress did not rush us toleave. Would recommend to family & friends. Read more
Excellent diner and friendly staff. Moderate prices. Awesome food.