Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Malvern, PA

Dined at Anthony's for the first time in many years with a party of eight. The dining room looks great and now has a full... service bar. All of our food was delicious and served in a timely manner. I did however show up with my wine since the Googledescription reads it is a BYOB restaurant still. Read more

I have been coming here for years with the family. The recent renovation looks amazing and now they can serve wine or beer or... some speciality cocktails. They have changed a lot over the years but always do a great job. The food was amazing and filling asalways. Read more

Pizza was good but service was not. Servers were rushing to close restaurant and one lady was very rude to us. Also servers... started cleaning up everything while we were still at the table within still 1h to close restaurant. Not coming back here andnot recommending to anyone. Read more

Very crowded for 5:30, Saturday. The wait, they don't accept reservations, was absolutely worth it. I had the chicken piccata,... and it was one of the best I've ever enjoyed. The lemony sauce was creamy and flavorful. Plenty of lovely little capers forevery bite. The chicken was tender, lightly browned and just perfect. Accompanying the very generous portion of my main entreewas another huge portion of spaghetti in marinara. Delicious. I brought most of it home for Sunday leftovers. I would have likea bit more zing in the marinara sauce but it wasn't b look and. It could have used more garlic, in my opinion. Both dishes weredelicious. For dessert my friend and I shared a slice of pumpkin cheesecake which was fresh and creamy. Pumpkiny yet stillcheesecake. Delicious. The pricing was reasonable especially for the portion size. The restaurant evidently acquired a liquorlicense and now sp ki gets a bar just inside the entrance. Handy place to have since there were enty of people waiting for atable. Nice family friendly restaurant with a wonderful, warm staff that are not affected or smug...which you frequently comeacross dining in the main line. I highly recommend this restaurant for a great Italian meal and a lovely evening out for dinner.My dining companions both loved their meals as well.: shrimp scampi and chicken marsala. I didn't try the shrimp scampi butsampled a bite of the chicken marsala and it too was perfection. Tge marsala sauce was bursting with flavor and the mushroomswere cooked to perfection. The chicken was cooked to the same perfection as my piccata. Hats off to the talent in the kitchenfor a beautiful meal that I'm sure more than just our group enjoyed Saturday evening. We'll be back and looking forward to it. Read more

Even though it's renovated, the space is super noisy. Too many hard surfaces. Salads are good but 7.25$ for a piece of chicken... added to an entree salad makes it $20. I know food prices have gone up but that's crazy. Read more

Very disappointed in the gummy, undercooked spaghetti with shrimp scampi. They claim spaghetti is homemade but it sure didn't... taste so. Some shrimp on the top of dish were fresh and the others were a different quality. I suggest sticking to pizza whengoing here! Waitress was snippy and of no help in rectifying this dish. Read more

Went on a Saturday night around 5:30 pm, got in before the rush. Food and service was excellent ! House made ravioli and Lasagna... were great, antipasto is the real deal. People know this place so it fills up, go early or wait in line, it's worth it. Read more

It was my first time visiting this establishment on 6/6/21. It was my first date. As a Culinarian/Foodie, I was impressed by... the atmosphere and especially the Food. Our Server Carol Ann, was very professional. We both started off with two Caesar sidesalads that came with our meals along the bread basket of delicious focaccia and a little dish of sundried tomato pesto oliveoil, and the Calamari Fritti, the salads were very delicious and the dressing along with the homemade croutons were bothflavorful. The Calamari was prepared and cooked to perfection, nice light and crispy coating and the marinara paired well. Thencomes the entrees, my date ordered the Pasta Di Mare, a good amount of seafood and pasta ratio, he said the seafood was cookedperfectly, I tried a Scallop, it was succulent. I ordered the Spaghetti alla Granchio, it was a absolutely beautiful pasta dishw/ a rich and garlicky crab white wine marinara tossed in spaghetti, I requested extra garlic and it was perfect, I loved it! Iwould like to point out, when you're a bus boy, definitely be more outgoing with the customers, I know the ins and outs of thehospitality industry, it's always good to have good interaction with your guests who are dining in your establishment. Otherthan that observation, I would definitely without a doubt be back at Anthony's for another meal! Highly Recommended! Tell themCharlie sent ya! Read more