Reviews for La Piccola Casa in Mamaroneck, NY

I have to admit it , the food was good. Very traditional cooking with great authentic flavor. However, the service was... debatable a very grumpy actitud took a very delicious dish to a very un-tasteful experience. Read more

Consistently great food. A quiet gem for a great meal

Amazing service, amazing food. Will be coming back.

It is peaceful, clean, and tasty. Very nice two gentlemen.

I had dinner with my Best Friend and her better half for her Birthday on November 18, 2020 Wednesday. Food and atmosphere is... wonderful. The service excellent. Our service Mr Miguel made us feel at home. Thank you. I would return for another round ofgreat food and service. Love this little quaint place. So romantic :) Read more

I went here for dinner on a Saturday night, and I was excited to eat here since the reviews were good. As soon as a sat down the... waiter was rude and didn?t seem nice at all. We ordered calamari for our appetizer , and It was cold, chewy, and tasteless . Ilet It pass because I was hoping my entree would be good and I did not want to complain. I told the order nice and clear to thewaiter that I wanted chicken francese, and he even repeated back to me that I ordered chicken francese . He then brought mefilet of sole and demanded I said I wanted filet of sole. He didn?t even apologize and say sorry for his mistake. I had to sitthere for 15 minutes while the other people I was with were eating. The server completely disappeared for the rest of the nightbecause he knew he was at fault. The bus boys had to take care of us for the rest of the night while our server was outside onhis phone. I personally felt like they should have taken the appetizer off at least since they messed up my order, the appetizerwas not good, and since I had to wait and eat alone while everyone was done with their meal. My biggest complaint is the servicebecause the waiter we had definitely will make this restaurant go out of business by acting the way he did. Disappearing on yourtable and sitting outside on your phone and giving us a dirty look isn?t correct on his part at all. I will definitely not becoming back after this experience. Read more

First attempt to enjoy dinner here as I have been eying this spot since moving on this side of the county... storm has past,... skies clearing... sun peaking, despite such the waiter insisted it was ?impossible? to sit outside, after 2 other tries toexplain to me the storm is still coming and the wetness factor is present (no kidding). I was solo; only 2 tables of 4 inside,both seated at the window view. Alas the open ?lawn? furniture seating outside seemed a perfect destination with a lovely harborview. Simple wipe down with a napkin or a semi clean dish towel as suggested, would have worked fine for most locals. You werenot quite motivated or didn?t believe me. I get it. Next time... and there will be one as I saw you go outside to re-evaluate.A little too late as I was already in my car. I will revise my review then and may even bring a date. Maybe that would havehelped?? If you were full, I would absolutely understand... far from it :/ Read more

Fantastic food, quaint setting. Everything was delicious. Service was outstanding...attentive, but not pushy. The waiter knew... all about the food being served and answered all questions. We opted to sit outside which, between light cycles, could be a bitloud with the traffic, but overall the outdoor seating was nice with the view of the harbor. If you want a quieter, more privatedate setting, sit inside. Read more