Reviews for The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House in Manahawkin, NJ

I’ve heard nothing but good things about The Old Causeway. The atmosphere was awesome, and the staff was super friendly.... It’s an awesome menu!! Unfortunately my medium rare burger turned out to be a well done burger. Clam chowder and fish tacoswere delicious though. I thought it was a bit pricey for the quality, but I’ll go bad and try again! Read more

All of these years going to LBI and I've never tried this restaurant. Glad I finally did! Our server was fantastic. I splurged... and ordered the jumbo Alaskan king crab. Best crabs legs I've ever had. They fries were incredible too. I will definitelyreturn. Read more

So I've been here a few times, different times of day, different day. So no matter what always a great meal. Tonight I had... Yellow fin poke bowl for app, omg the freshness and flavor of the sauce incredible. Then shared the mussels in classic butterand garlic, for my entree salmon farro bowl salmon seasoned and grilled to perfection. Can't wait to go back to try somethingnew. Read more

Drink - Black Manhattan - delicious Starter - Catfish bites - fantastic Mains - 1) OC lobster tails (very good but a small dish... for $36 - would recommend a couple more pieces of asparagus, less cream sauce and some fresh bread). 2) Seared Swordfish special(beautiful filet perfectly cooked on top of a lump crab fried rice and grilled boo choy with a perfect soy sauce reduction -????omg this should be on the main menu, absolutely phenomenal) Desert - apple/cherry crumble. Took to go since we were full andenjoyed it tonight. Will for sure try the raw bar next time I’m back. Read more

There was a bit of a wait. But oh boy was it worth it. The service was Fast/great. The food was absolutely delicious 10 out of... 10. I would recommend this to anyone coming down to the shore to put this place on your list. Get there early or expect a littlewait, but you can get a cold drink at the bar while waiting... Read more

We both had the Filet mignon. It was out of this world! Tender, moist, juicy, like biting into butter! And my sweet potato,... delicious! Best dirty martini I’ve had in a while! Our go to place now if we want steaks! Read more

Great service great food! I had the best oysters ever I don't even know what they were called but they had tuna and fish eggs on... them top notch!! The best french fries and super friendly staff can't wait to go back there. Thanks Read more

Busy place. First time eating here. Bad acoustics but the food and service was great. I had the ceviche and then the potatoes... and cheese fritters. Then the filet mignon tips with Palenta peppers and onions and the shrimp and grits. Great food. Read more