Reviews for Carmelina in Markham, ON
Visited today for a business lunch. Service was great and staff very attentive. Small menu but perfect selection. There is... something for everyone. Fish, beef, lamb, pasta, seafood. We sat inside because the sun was very hot today but they have alovely patio and the inside is beautiful as well. Pricing was a bit on the higher side so gave 4 stars. Food was absolutelydelicious! Would definitely recommend and will be back. Read more
TLDR: most amazing restaurant to host your private outdoor patio dinner. Wedding celebration/private patio dinner: My husband... and I did a small intimate belated-wedding/marriage celebration dinner with our immediate families and few close friends. Wereally wanted to host something outdoors to be covid-friendly. Peter and the team were spectacular. They were extremelyaccommodating in the planning process and provided amazing service and execution of the dinner during the night. We were ableto use the patio entirely. The fountain, greenery, and the string lights were so beautiful. We were able to Bluetooth speakersome chill music. The wine was amazing. The food was delicious. I'm so happy with how the night went. I highly recommendanyone to host their private parties here! Thank you Carmelina?? Read more
Updated Review: my partner and I returned here last night for dinner and I was very displeased after having such a good... experience the first time... It was very slow Monday night atmosphere in the restaurant. They had the front area open despitethe cold weather, and it was quite drafty inside. Our server was very nice but quite clumsy and dropped our bruschetta all overthe table, we waited for her to come back with a new bruschetta... But it looks like they just re-plated the previous one, verynot impressed. And she dropped some of the vegetables from my partner's main course as well (she did bring more over after andwas constantly apologizing). The fungi risotto I ordered was very bland. We ordered dessert and she cleared the plates, but thenwe waited over half an hour for her to come with our bill. I had high expectations for this restaurant after visiting the firsttime but I don't think we will be returning. Previous Review: This place was absolutely wonderful, so many helpful staffmembers. Food was amazing and there was even a gentleman singing, Playing the piano and guitar in the dining room. Highlyrecommended, I will be returning Read more
Great good & amazing services in a warm cozy and elaborate ambience. Everything was delicious, from bread (very good olive oil)... to grilled mushroom appetizers to the main dishes. The pasta was a bit soft for my liking (you can request for it to be cookedmore al dente) but the seafood was fresh and the sauce was amazing. Great tiramisu (could use more liquor and coffee). Price wasright for the portion. Will definitely come back. Read more
Amazing Italian food, service and environment. Live music played and personalized. One gentleman even played and sang a classic... Chinese song. Our server was kind and fun, played with our child too. Clean beautiful interior design. Definitely a hidden gemin Markham. Read more
Amazing food and excellent service. We took our kids here on March break to show them what fine dinning is all about. Definitely... be back the next time we are in town. Read more
First time at this cozy restaurant. The service and food was very good. Portions were quite large. My favourite dish was the... risotto funghi. Plan to visit again! Read more
Valentina was amazing. Good friendly service. Good food and good ???? Ask for Valentina to give you the best service. Owners... note - give her a raise or bonus. She is good Read more