Reviews for Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta Italian Restaurant in Martinsville, NJ

It's good when its fresh my next review well be on a frssh pie .. hoping to see 6 to 8 in personal pies cheap and affordable..... it's a struggle to eat fresh and healthy under 10 a day for lunch.. Was gonna give 3 stars but even hungery I tossed this 4 to5 hour old pizza and I was hungry. Do something new make small personal pies. Easy solution for food quality during slowerbusiness. Disappointed customers or displaying old pizza is just as bad compared to waste. If you dont like my review i dontcare..least it's only one review. Read more

I?m not sure what?s being going on lately but the last couple times we have ordered it?s been horrible. Ordered a caesar salad... with chicken and there was salmon in my salad. Owner made right by giving us credit but still?luckily I don?t have a fishallergy because that could?ve been a lawsuit. Ordered penne vodka and got a raging stomach ache. The pasta was extremely mushyand over cooked. We will be giving this place a break for a while. I really love their Caesar salad and house dressing but it?snot cheap food and I feel the quality is starting to lack for what you?re paying. Read more

This place is FANTASTIC the food is amazing. The mussels Fra diavlo is so good I can eat the sauce alone. And the chicken... portobello is to die for. The only place I don't mind paying more for Read more

Gnocchi is literal mush and totally messed up sandwich. Also an actual garlic clove was found on one of the sandwiches? like how... does that happen (clearly deliberate after we had to go back and get the right sandwiches). Management has gotten real bad Read more

Pizza was fire!!! I miss north eastern pizza now living in Miami. This was a treat. Great food besides the Zzaaaaaa too!!!!!

The food wasn't that good Had to ask if they put cheese in the chef Salad it was so thin you couldn't barely see it.small ... Portions Charged for water that was a first!!! Tried to call the main office good luck with that Won't be going back broughtpeople very disappointed Read more

Excellent customer service. Food is great & made fresh, and the wait time when ordering take out is rarely more than 20 minutes.... Myself and my family's favorite local Italian restaurant! ???????????? Read more

Panatieri's is a small, NJ-specific chain that consistently puts out good pizza. I've been to a few locations and all have had... great pizza. This time around, I went with the Brooklyn and the tortellini slices. The Brooklyn had a crisp base, but a fluffyinterior like a delicious dinner roll. The cheese was fresh and buttery. The sauce was sweet and delicious. The tortellini slicealso had a crisp, thin base and a thinner, crispier crust. The crust was a bit dry, but the slice was cheesy and delicious. Thetortellini slice was also very filling. Overall, Panatieri's has good pizza. -@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram. Read more