Reviews for New York Burger Bar in Massapequa, NY
Friendly people and tasty food but in the end $48 for 2 burgers was too large a hurdle to rate it 3 stars. The burgers ordered... were both their cheapest meat w bacon, American, caramelized onions and sautéed mushrooms. 1 burger had hot peppers. Ourpoutine appetizer were on point but the $13? 2 sodas $7 Tip 2x tax In the end lunch with my son was 85 bucks. I couldn't seemy family as repeat customers. Sorry it just misses bc of price Read more
Excellent food, excellent service for a considerably busy night, pretty wide menu selection. Most restaurants that don't... necessarily devote their craft to making burgers often times will cook your burger slightly off kilter. But this place gets itspot on every time. This isn't all that important to me, but it's impressive to see that much attention to detail. The onlything is I don't recall seeing a menu section for beers, only cocktails. That may be more convenient for beerconnoisseurs. Overall, would reccomend. Read more
2nd review 2022~I chose New York Burger Bar again because I have been here a few times and like the food and the atmosphere but... tonight was different. We sat at the bar for drinks and dinner instead of the dining room. It was a nice switch up because wehad the perfect bartender named Nino. He was very attentive and quite charismatic. He really added some unexpected fun to ournight. I had the Greek salad with grilled chicken & red wine vinaigrette which was so fresh and very delicious. I took halfhome. Yes, I know it's a burger bar but I wanted a salad. My friend had the Belmont steak burger & her daughter ordered the Macattack burger. They both enjoyed their meals. We already made a plan to come back here the next time we meet up. See you nexttime Nino. 1st review in 2021~Brought my family here today and what a treat it was. Our waitress was very friendly. I wish Igot her name so her boss could see this. Speaking of her boss, he brought a free sample of their newest item, pork wings withAsian Sauce for us to try and they were absolutely delicious. I didn't even get to take a picture of them because we devouredthem so fast. My son ordered the Mac attack Burger, my sister got the grilled chicken with avocado sandwich and I ordered thebuffalo chicken sandwich with coleslaw. Everything was excellent. We will be back for sure. Read more
Great place! I will definitely be returning. Food was fantastic, my Kobe beef burger was cooked to perfection. I loved the... sweet potato fries with marshmallow dipping sauce, drink menu great too ???? this is a good place to stop if you are in the areafor a nice selection of burgers and drinks! Read more
I came in once for my birthday and I hope to find the time to come back. The meals were satisfying and the bartender kept me... informed while I was waiting. I give it a pass for now. Read more
Picked up a to go order on recomendation from a friend. Place seems pretty good and im interested in trying more food and will... likely return. The food was a bit pricey compared to even other premium burger places and i wasnt blown away by the burger. Itwas tasty and of good quality but i didnt prefer the way the burger is formed as a very thick small patty kinda like a ball. Ilike a burger to be about an inch at most thick and a wide bread sized patty so you can get all flavors in each bite. I willgive this place another shot becsuse it was tasty and there were other items that appealed to me. I just dont often spend 26bucks on a burger and fries. The sweet potato fries kinda fell flat with bein a bit of a soggy salty mess and the whippedmarshmallow sauce didnt have enough sweetness to combat the salty moosh of fries. Perhaps a lighter hand in applying salt or atouch of cinnamon to the mashmallow could help. The location itself is pretty nice with that rustic urban cowboy style commonamongst these types of places. I didnt get a drink but did notice their selection was nice for both beers and liquors. I willupgrade my review if my next meal warrants a more memorable experience. Read more
This place is great with one minor problem, the bathrooms are not the most well kept. The food is great, I recommend the... Brooklyn Cyclone burger or the North Shore burger. The service and atomosphere is wonderful! Overall a good experience. Read more
On the pricey side, but it makes sense considering how fresh and tasty everything is. If your looking for a flavorful, juicy,... thick burger this place is definitely for you. There’s so many options to choose from which I love. Really appreciated theservice and will be back again. Read more