Reviews for Sergio's in Massapequa, NY
Went for a psychic dinner. I want to start by saying owner, wait staff and food were all very good. But they had so many people... mushed in there it was ridiculous- horrible ! and the psychic just talked and talked barely read anyone. It was one of the worstexperiences I ever had, being so crowded forced to sit with strangers, I had reservations for this way in advance. Theirgreediness to squeeze so many people in such a small space, we should have been made aware these are the conditions they weregoing to subject us to Read more
I've been coming here for ever. I now live 4 hours north but when I come here Michael treats me like gold and what ever he can... do to please his customers is the only thing you will experience. The prices are so reasonable and the service is excellent. Michael is here with every table and sees to it that customer is served and taken care of and every meal is great. I will alwayscome back as long as Mike is opened I will always come when I am here. Thank you to all those who work here and do what they do. Read more
We had a party for my in-laws 50th wedding anniversary here. The service was great, the food was amazing, the staff was... welcoming and the live music was great. It's absolutely the best fra diavlo my husband and I have had. The francese was alsoreally lemony, which was a perk for us. Absolutely loved it here and can't wait to go back! Read more
Used to be so much better. I used to go there all the time with my family but over the years what used to be a quiet dinner out... turned into hearing cover artists singing so loudly that we can barely hear each other. Food is great and owner is wonderful butwe stopped going due to the loud music from the other room. Read more
Was invited to wedding rehersal dinner by family. A little dated but I think that what gave this place its old-school... atmosphere. The owner was very nice. Food was fantastic. So good forgot to take photos. Read more
Went for a Frank Sinatra tribute show and had a fabulous time. Food was good fried calamari was chewy that's why I gave 4 stars... instead of 5. Wait staff was very helpful with the exception That they forgot about my ice tea but it was busy so no big deal.Great night so much fun. Definitely going to go back probably for the Neil diamond show. Read more
First time went there for the Elvis show by Steve Mitchell, would go back for the food and other entertainment! Our orders were... taken promptly, and prepared and served without a long wait. Family atmosphere, personal attention, delicious Italian dishesmake Sergio's one of the best restaurants around. It can feel crowded for a larger group of people, but it is very comfortablefor a private party or a dinner for two. Read more
This was our first time there. The food was great at a fair price. The service was exceptional! The owners couldn't be more... friendly if the tried. We were treated liked family. Will definitely be going back. Read more