Reviews for An Italian Affair in Massena, NY
Service is excellent. My only complaint is the marinara sauce has changed. I loved the old sauce. This new one was straight... tomato sauce only. No spices or onions in it. It did not go well with my pepperoni roll or the garlic knots. The knots weregreat except they tasted like someone poured garlic salt all over them. They were way too salty. Please go back to how they useto be! Thank you! Read more
Good prices, food tasted great, tap water not good at all.
Service was good. Bought some subs that could have been really good. Very dry with very little toppings. One was a steak sub and... the other was Italian. It felt like they only filled the buns halfway and that you were eating a loaf of bread. It's too badbecause I've had them there over the years and they were always very good before that. Read more
We were exhausted from a long plane and car ride, and hoped to grab a late dinner before settling in. We arrived about 40... minutes prior to close and asked the server if we were cutting it too close to dine in. She was very pleasant, patient, and toldus not to feel rushed. Food came out quickly and everything tasted great, especially the cheese curds. We really appreciated theaccommodation and hospitality. Read more
As a restaurant manager, this is one of the cleanest restaurants I have ever seen. When the team is cleaning the walls it is... always a good sight. Portions are ridiculously large, my food was so big I couldn't fit on the table. This is a 1st for me. Keepit up, the dedication shows. Read more
Perfect family restaurant! From a variety of delicious pizzas to calzones to full dinners, burgers, wraps, salads.... Something... for everyone! Just redecorated and it's beautiful! Reasonable prices and a friendly waitress staff! Manga! ?? Read more
We got a few appetizers for dinner. The blue cheese chips were AMAZING. As was the garlic bread! The Mac and cheese bites were... not that special. The menu said "onion petals", but when you actually order online, it's onion rings. Good but nothingspecial. Good food for good prices! Read more
The photo attached is what you get for "very well done" - to me that looks like a normal pizza. The cheese on a normal pizza... from Italian Affair is melted but tastes like melted mozzarella you'd have in hot meatball sub, without any of the flavor ofactually toasted cheese. To get a pizza that tastes like a pizza you have to re-bake it at home for another 5-10 minutes or askfor "extra well done" to just get it normal. I've ordered pizzas over two dozen times and times, with and without asking forextra well done, and what I describe above is consistent every time. That being said, the crust (when cooked enough) has a verygood taste, and the sauce and cheese are also very good quality and taste when baked long enough. Read more