Reviews for Mama Lisa Restaurant in Mastic, NY
one of the most overrated restaurants on the island. it’s always a 50/50 chance of enjoying my order for me, but definitely a... decent enough and affordable go to. tip: pizza is always a safer option than pasta if you’re ordering take out, they DROWN thepasta in sauce & cheese. & if you’re thinking “that actually sounds great to me” trust me it’s to the point where itdoes ruin the dish. Read more
????? again had to go stock up on the BEST PIZZA, CHICKEN ROLLS AND SPINACH PINWHEELS. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. **Thank you to the... owner who took the time to reply. I will be coming back and stocking up on as many items as possible. ????? 5 star placesdeserve great reviews. I think that I might need a moving truck. Nothing like having a tasty New York Pizza. HIGHLYRECOMMENDED. Great selection of food, pizza, desserts. Delicious pizza. Read more
Guys I gotta give you average. Order chicken marsal could definitely 100% make it better myself at my house. Not enough flavor... needs more wine needs more something I had to go home and tweak it to eat it gods honest truth. The prices you’re chargingmake sure your flavors are spot on. Read more
This restaurant is usually always good. A go to for our family for everything down to big birthday parties but lately the food... has been just okay. Their customer service is great but the food has been coming out so sloppily made. It’s getting worseevery time, I figured I’d order early and I’d get a better result but I just got my delivery at 4:00pm and it looks superrushed. $85 dollar order and everything looks like they just didn’t care how it was sent out to someone’s home. It sucksbecause there aren’t many good Italian restaurants out here. I think this will be my last order.. Read more
Food and service was amazing! 1st time in NY and it lived up to what they say about the good Italian food here. Thanks from... Minnesota! Read more
Loved it. I ordered a chicken parmigiana, chicken Alfredo and calamari and it was delicious. I loved the warm bread they serve... before we order. I would come back again. Read more
We called in advance for reservations and asked to be seated in the dining room. They sat us in the corner of where the pizza... area is. I asked if we can be seated in dining room as per my reservation request and was told no because of covid, mean whilethe party that was supposed to sit 6ft next to us refuse to sit there and they were seated in dining room. I'm furious, I hadguests with me from out of town party of 4 and was never so embarrassed. We are not kids you sit in the corner of a pizzajoint.. The table was up against the wall where there was dried sauce on it and the molding around the window next to the tablewas filthy. I'm done dining at this Pizzeria. Food is great but your better off with take out. This is the second time withdining room/reservations issues they ruined Valentines days for us as well apologized and then asked me to remove the one starrating I gave them, which I did. and now the second time this....hopefully these guys get smart and get an experienced host.I'll be sure to inform my executive friends about this experience as well. Read more
I ordered delivery for the Penne a la Vodka from here and was so disappointed. I’d expected from the rave reviews that it... would be great, but the sauce was bland and did not have any flavor and while the chicken was cooked well, it also lackedflavor. I wish I had cheese or salt on the side to save this dish, but it was so bad that I couldn’t finish, unfortunately.This might have been an off night for the restaurant, but I probably wouldn’t give this place a second chance. Read more