Reviews for Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant in Matamoras, PA

Ordered from doordash. Poorly explained descriptions for food items. Ordered buffalo chicken cheese steak. The chicken was re... used because it was marinated in Italian dressing, I could taste and see it. The cheese was on the sides of the bread, coldwhere you can still see the square cutout of it. Was Luke warm on arrival. Also ordered cheese fries, while arriving "hot" thetest pull had no cheese, fry just broke and that's when I realized these psychos use mozzarella or something else, not propercheese dip or sauce for cheese fries. It turned into a soggy mold within 20 seconds forcing to eat with a fork to continue.Didn't finish after my 2 initial bite...Technically food, but never again. Read more

Always nice and pleasant to talk to. Quickly got my order and I was on my way with the yummy pizza in no time.

So good! The personal pizzas will easily feed 2 and we?re delish. Fresh veggies added a perfect crunch to the veggie pizza. ... Service was quick and friendly. Restrooms were clean. Definitely found our new lunch spot when we trek from New England toSouthern PA! Read more

Food was very good servers were very friendly. I had the eggplant parmesan dinner and my companion had the chicken Caesar. Both... were very good. Read more

Enjoyable place to dine and delicious food...i had the Italian wrap and the BF had the cheeseburger he said was very good, juicy... and tasty....although very busy our server was very sweet n nice????????. Read more

The biggest pizza was much more than enough for 8 people. It tasted good. Awesome!

Big fan of goodfellas so no surprise I loved the atmosphere here. People working were super nice and recommended some slices for... me. I ended up getting a slice of the chicken Parmesan pizza. First this pizza was enormous soo awesome job there. It was not myfavor pizza but I could be the toppings a choose. Everyone else seemed to love it. I would probably give the pizza a 7 or 8 outof ten meaning it?s worth grabbing a slice. If I?m in the area, I definitely want to try it again. All and all the restaurant isa solid 5 out of 5. Great service and amazing food! Be sure to check them out! Read more

Overall an excellent experience. I reserve the right to come back and edit this later though! I ordered a bunch of stuff to go... for other family members. The pizza is huge, as you can see from the pictures. The brown and white pizza is a stuffed barbequedchicken pizza my daughter ordered. She was able to eat ONE slice. Lol I got the two slices, plain and the "Captains". I couldnot finish the second slice, and I am a big eater! The waitress was very helpful and patient. The staff were all friendly. Theplace was very clean. The atmosphere was surprisingly nice! It had a little outdoor seating area and very nice ambiance. Niceart on the walls, both murals and pictures. This seemed more like a stand alone restaurant than a place in a "strip mall". Ithink they far outclass the rest of the tenants here. My daughter has raved about this place for quite a while, so I broughther today so I could try it. Back to the pizza.... for some background, I was a pizza man when I was younger and ran apizzeria. I am VERY picky. The first thing I will say is this is the best pizza I ever had in Pennsylvania. But that's a low barto overcome. The crust was excellent. Excellent. The cheese and toppings were fine. The sauce was the only thing I was not ahuge fan of. It's not that it was bad, and this is COMPLETELY subjective of course. It was the weak point to me for sure. That'sthe only negative I have, and it's really not negative. Just a matter of taste. Read more